Is Josh Allen the most overrated QB in the league?

Loose

Retired Legend
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
48,823
Reputation
2,907
Daps
141,902
Weird bump ngl, he aint why they lost this game. He wasn't great but definitely not why they lost.
 

KidJSoul

Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
19,028
Reputation
3,754
Daps
82,772
No he's not overrated.

Many people highlight his turnovers. Most people at best put him 3 behind Mahomes and Burrow.

So no, he's not overrated by definition when we all know his flaws and knock him accordingly for it. Who else is better? Lawrence? Herbert? Hurts? Lamar?
 

the next guy

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
40,113
Reputation
1,599
Daps
38,402
Reppin
NULL
No he's not overrated.

Many people highlight his turnovers. Most people at best put him 3 behind Mahomes and Burrow.

So no, he's not overrated by definition when we all know his flaws and knock him accordingly for it. Who else is better? Lawrence? Herbert? Hurts? Lamar?
Hurts and Herbert
 
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
39,601
Reputation
-17,826
Daps
84,274
Reppin
NULL
Yall love to be prisoners of the moment.

Josh Allen is the greatest talent in the history of the sport. Bet against him at your peril. FTR I'm the guy who told yall not to bet against Josh Dobbs for 7 years. Now he's cashing those checks I wrote.

Josh Allen is a beast. He'll win championships eventually.
 

KidJSoul

Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
19,028
Reputation
3,754
Daps
82,772
Hurts and Herbert

See this is what I meant. There's really not many guys better than Allen when you actually count it all. Even hurts - Hurts got off to a slow start this year as well, and YOU KNOW he'd be struggling if he had Allen's supporting cast.

Herbert has a case, but also better supporting cast.

Allen has outplayed Lamar in their recent matches and can make more throws than he can.
Favre was throwing over 20 picks fairly regularly. This isn't even close.

Allen has a lower pick rate than Peyton for godsakes.

I wish my titans had josh allen I'd gladly take him tf :mjlol:
Exactly. People love to shyt on Allen but he'd be a clear upgrade at QB over 25 teams in the league.

There's really only like 4 teams that wouldn't feel the need to trade for him. Only 2 that you feel are confirmed without a doubt better.
 

PHamm

Superstar
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
9,466
Reputation
1,129
Daps
19,632
No he's not overrated.

Many people highlight his turnovers. Most people at best put him 3 behind Mahomes and Burrow.

So no, he's not overrated by definition when we all know his flaws and knock him accordingly for it. Who else is better? Lawrence? Herbert? Hurts? Lamar?
Hurts and Lamar are DEFINITELY better.
 

Raquinotj

#NBATwitter #NBAReddit #6ixRings #PatsNation
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
15,701
Reputation
-933
Daps
58,591
Reppin
City of champions BAWSTON
See this is what I meant. There's really not many guys better than Allen when you actually count it all. Even hurts - Hurts got off to a slow start this year as well, and YOU KNOW he'd be struggling if he had Allen's supporting cast.

Herbert has a case, but also better supporting cast.

Allen has outplayed Lamar in their recent matches and can make more throws than he can.



Exactly. People love to shyt on Allen but he'd be a clear upgrade at QB over 25 teams in the league.

There's really only like 4 teams that wouldn't feel the need to trade for him. Only 2 that you feel are confirmed without a doubt better.


Allen has a bad supporting cast? He has a top 5 Wide receiver(Diggs), top 3 Tight End Duo(Knox a Pro bowler las year, Dalton Kincaid having one of the best TE rookie seasons in the history of the NFL) a decent running game and TWO pro bowlers(Dion Dawkins and Mitch Morse) on the offensive line. Not to mention a defense that keeps them in games. What else does he need? Derrick Henry?

The Bills currently have 12 players that have made the pro bowl.
 
Last edited:
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
16,276
Reputation
2,260
Daps
53,051
Reppin
Continental U.S.
No he's not overrated.

Many people highlight his turnovers. Most people at best put him 3 behind Mahomes and Burrow.

So no, he's not overrated by definition when we all know his flaws and knock him accordingly for it. Who else is better? Lawrence? Herbert? Hurts? Lamar?
Currently CJ a rookie, Jared fukkkng Goff, Bayker fukking Mayfield, Herbert, Dak, Noodle arm Tua, Hurst, Lamar to an extent, are all playing the position better than Allen this year.
 

Biscayne

Ocean air
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
34,264
Reputation
5,735
Daps
104,024
Reppin
Cruisin’
Weird bump ngl, he aint why they lost this game. He wasn't great but definitely not why they lost.
Stop!!! That Bills defense as firing on all cylinders. Cook had a running game for the ages. It was literally Josh’s INT before the half that gifted Denver 3pts, and his boggled hand off to cook, is what cost them this game. I’ve never seen a QB make so many blunders, and it’s never his fault. :mjlol:
 
Top