Is Josh Allen the most overrated QB in the league?

[...and some waffle fries]

Black qb success is always met with skepticism. The white lens always takes the glass is half empty perspective.

White mediocrity is always met with a irrational sense of optimism. Any inkling of success will be propped up and used as basis on why they deserve to be in the league even if its 1 game.

 

[Rekkapryde]

Having Diggs helped him immensely. Diggs is one of the most underrated receivers in the league (despite leading the league in receptions and yards last season), but that’s another thread.

100% Agree

 

[Rekkapryde]

Black qb success is always met with skepticism. The white lens always takes the glass is half empty perspective.

White mediocrity is always met with a irrational sense of optimism. Any inkling of success will be propped up and used as basis on why they deserve to be in the league even if its 1 game.

This nikka spittin

 

[Chip Skylark]

Each one of those guys has had the privilege of being surrounded with better talent than Lamar.

Mahomes has Cheetah and Kelce. Both were Pro Bowlers with Alex Smith at QB
Russ has DK and Lockett.
Watson had Nuke whose hasn't skipped a beat since he left Houston
Allen has Diggs and Beasley. Diggs was a beast in MIN (still underrated smh) and Beasley was a solid WR in Dallas
shyt even Baker has Landry and OBJ who were elite before Cleveland, along with Chubb and Hunt in the backfield

The first 3 are 3 of the best QB in the league, but they've had more to work with than Lamar has. Lamar's best target is Mark Andrews, who's great in his own right, but not those guys.

I'm not even gonna get into coaching with Greg Roman calling the plays

Hard to say he's the most overrated because when the Ravens lose he gets most of the criticism despite having less around him than his contemporaries. That said, there's some things that Lamar can improve on, but I don't think he's overrated.

Now, Baker on the other hand...

And Lamar has been blessed to have a better defense than everyone you mentioned, a better rushing attack (other than the browns) and a better offensive line

Lamar is great and anyone saying he’s overrated is a Dumbass but they’re crowning Josh too soon he’s only had one good season

 

[Amare's Right Hook]

I have is rookie card so no, people hate but they wish they had him.

 

[KFBF]

I think it's Herbert and I'm.a chargers fan .he's played well no doubt but they're.acti.g like he's a top10
QB after.one season.

 

[Marc Spector]

Nwver saw the hype with allen as he inherited a playoff team that added a top 5 WR in the league.

 

[Chip Skylark]

2021
BUF
270
1
0
79.7

2020
BUF
4,544
37
10
107.2

2019
BUF
3,089
20
9
85.3

2018
BUF
2,074
10
12
67.9

 

[Th3G3ntleman]

I think it's Herbert and I'm.a chargers fan .he's played well no doubt but they're.acti.g like he's a top10
QB after.one season.

Because he is lol

 

[93 til]

And Lamar has been blessed to have a better defense than everyone you mentioned, a better rushing attack (other than the browns) and a better offensive line

Lamar is great and anyone saying he’s overrated is a Dumbass but they’re crowning Josh too soon he’s only had one good season

Touchè

 

[Po pimp]

Because he is lol

In no order:
Mahomes
Russ
Brady
Rodgers
Watson
Murray
Stafford
Jackson
Dak
Winston

Thats 10 right there I’d take over Herbert. Possibly even Allen and Burrow too.

 

[Th3G3ntleman]

In no order:
Mahomes
Russ
Brady
Rodgers
Watson
Murray
Stafford
Jackson
Dak
Winston

Thats 10 right there I’d take over Herbert. Possibly even Allen and Burrow too.

Nope.

Mahomes
Brady
Rodgers
Russ - likely won't be at the end of the year.

Herbert is going to expose the rest of this list as looking a bit casual.

Won't even entertain the Allen/Burrow shyt as its just troll.

 

[Eye Cue DA COLI GAWD]

No it's Baker Mayfield and it's not even close I mean he went number 1 I had a white co worker at the time tell me straight up if Lamar Jackson was white it wouldn't of been a question he would've went number 1 and we all know that.

Allen has improved every season and he's a dual threat he earned his stripes.

What the fukk has Mayfield done that I have to see him in every fukking commercial besides being

Once you finish your hissy fit, check Baker & Allen's stats and hola back

 

[Ohene]

this thread is about josh allen, why the fukk is lamar jackson in the convo

Op mentioned Jackson

 

[Po pimp]

Nope.

Mahomes
Brady
Rodgers
Russ - likely won't be at the end of the year.

Herbert is going to expose the rest of this list as looking a bit casual.

Won't even entertain the Allen/Burrow shyt as its just troll.

What has Herbert done that makes him better than the last six on my list?