Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen?
- Thread starter 28 Gramz
- Start date
supertrekker
Superstar
The OP means pure raw talent.
Apprentice
RIP Doughboy Roc
Not really a true difference between Prime Mahomes and Prime Rodgers imo
Give 12 Rodgers, DeSean Jackson, Percy Harvin and Gronk in a Reid system and he’d look like the greatest to ever play
The shyt Mahomes doing now Rodgers was doing and this same convo was coming up. I remember people would say Brady is the goat but Rodgers is the most talented to play
Give 12 Rodgers, DeSean Jackson, Percy Harvin and Gronk in a Reid system and he’d look like the greatest to ever play
The shyt Mahomes doing now Rodgers was doing and this same convo was coming up. I remember people would say Brady is the goat but Rodgers is the most talented to play
Thatrogueassdiaz
We're on the blood path now
Hes up there but hes also in the perfect system for him. I say Rodgers.
Piff Perkins
Veteran
Rodgers in like...2011. Hell even after that. You could tell then he was the prototype for what was coming.
And let’s not forget Brady. Nearly every year in Nov/Dec/Jan/Feb I’d be watching in awe and sometimes disgust. Flawless.
Mahomes will be my answer in a few years. He reminds me of both. You just know he’s about to score. You can tell when he’s about to drive 75 yards down the field. And unlike the Packers, he’s in an organization that surrounds him with weapons and aren’t complacent. He’s getting another chip before he retires.
And let’s not forget Brady. Nearly every year in Nov/Dec/Jan/Feb I’d be watching in awe and sometimes disgust. Flawless.
Mahomes will be my answer in a few years. He reminds me of both. You just know he’s about to score. You can tell when he’s about to drive 75 yards down the field. And unlike the Packers, he’s in an organization that surrounds him with weapons and aren’t complacent. He’s getting another chip before he retires.
2011 Rodgers had a type of pristine deep ball accuracy from any platform (throw on the run, in the pocket, falling away, etc.) that was exceptional
2020 Wilson has a perfect touch ball that is just phenomenal
Tom Brady's second peak (2014-2018) was something else from a pure fundamental QB perspective - A1 Pocket presence, quick decision making, great ability to read and dissect defense pre and post-snap, CLUTCH as fukk, great velocity on bullet passes on short and intermediate throws, etc. That's part of why they were able to get far with Gronk and Edelman being their best skill position players. They didn't have much of a consistent run game, or vertical receivers.
2020 Wilson has a perfect touch ball that is just phenomenal
Tom Brady's second peak (2014-2018) was something else from a pure fundamental QB perspective - A1 Pocket presence, quick decision making, great ability to read and dissect defense pre and post-snap, CLUTCH as fukk, great velocity on bullet passes on short and intermediate throws, etc. That's part of why they were able to get far with Gronk and Edelman being their best skill position players. They didn't have much of a consistent run game, or vertical receivers.
I still put Rodgers ahead of him. He has done incredible things without much support from the organization. Mahomes was fortunate enough to step into a perfect situation from a standpoint of coaching and surrounding cast.
Cel 510 kid ados forever
Veteran
When did rodgers back pedal 20 yards and make a 30 yard pass completion
When did rodgers get chased on the sidelines than contort his body and make a sidearm pass for 40 yards
Stop piff
Mahomes does stuff we never seen
Controversy
Superstar
Brady
We gotta see how Pat performs when his offense is devoid of talent
We gotta see how Pat performs when his offense is devoid of talent
Amare's Right Hook
Southeast World Champion
Tommy Fraizer >
2011 Rodgers is the best I've ever seen