Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen?

Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen

  • Yes

    Votes: 141 56.2%

  • No

    Votes: 110 43.8%
  • Total voters
    251
Bboystyle

Bboystyle

Bang Bang Packers gang!
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
46,115
Reputation
1,301
Daps
76,818
Reppin
So. Cal
Truefan31 said:
no he isn’t. Rodgers first three years as an actual starter he has less tds and more ints. And less yards. Rodgers was 86 tds and 31 ints.

and mahomes hasn’t completed this year yet either.....

and that’s not a knock on Rodgers. But mahomes is the evolution.
Click to expand...


Im referring to the actual stat ( all time TD to INT ratio), not what someone did their first 3 years.

Besides, why dont nikkas knock Mahomes for having the most stacked offense? Monatana got that flock for it and so did other QBs. Or does he get a pass for some reason? :patrice:
 
T

Truefan31

Superstar
Joined
Jan 9, 2016
Messages
4,420
Reputation
661
Daps
13,182
Maluma's Wallet said:
Im referring to the actual stat ( all time TD to INT ratio), not what someone did their first 3 years.

Besides, why dont nikkas knock Mahomes for having the most stacked offense? Monatana got that flock for it and so did other QBs. Or does he get a pass for some reason? :patrice:
Click to expand...

Because Mahomes made that offense such a stacked offense. Montana was great too, but Mahomes is seriously on another level coming out the gate.

Let me remind you Mahomes missed some games last year too, and there's still a few games left to be played this year. The disparity will be even greater. And again that's not a knock on Rodgers, he's still one of the greats.
 
28 Gramz

28 Gramz

How U Luv That???
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
11,287
Reputation
1,535
Daps
34,196
Reppin
Tre-4,North Carolina
holidayinn21 said:
Andy Reid creation. There was a reason why he was a project coming out of college
Click to expand...

You cant create super human arm strength+mobility+accuracy and the ability to flick a football like a MLB shortstop. I do agree that Reid is maximizing his skillset with all the speed and trick plays but hes not just a product of the system.
 
holidayinn21

holidayinn21

:SmugMoneyMike:
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
18,018
Reputation
2,430
Daps
54,841
Reppin
The mutha****in BX
BucciMane said:
Creation?:usure:.


First round picks are not creations.:mjlol:.


That's not to say that Reid hasn't enhanced what Mahomes has done and can do, but the talent was there.
Click to expand...
Yes, creation. Took an Air Raid QB who couldn't read defenses and turned him into the most dominant player in the league in just a few years.

Mahomes is not putting up these numbers in Mike McCarthy's offense with Jordy Nelson as his best receiver
 
Bboystyle

Bboystyle

Bang Bang Packers gang!
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
46,115
Reputation
1,301
Daps
76,818
Reppin
So. Cal
Truefan31 said:
Because Mahomes made that offense such a stacked offense. Montana was great too, but Mahomes is seriously on another level coming out the gate.

Let me remind you Mahomes missed some games last year too, and there's still a few games left to be played this year. The disparity will be even greater. And again that's not a knock on Rodgers, he's still one of the greats.
Click to expand...


Breh, when i saw him play during his SB run, his WRs and Kelce were running wide open on some plays. I think his mobility and accuracy makes that offense much more dangerous but you cant act like he doesnt have weapons for days. Not a knock on him but its still a fact.
 
Bboystyle

Bboystyle

Bang Bang Packers gang!
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
46,115
Reputation
1,301
Daps
76,818
Reppin
So. Cal
bl2k8 said:
Mahomes is about to have 2 MVPs in 3 years, one Super Bowl ring, one super bowl MVP and is the favourite to win it again this year. Crown is deserving
Click to expand...

He aint a shoe in at MVP this year :dahell:

And being a favorite to make the SB means jack shyt in the NFL.

Crowning denied
 
Frump

Frump

Superstar
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
15,947
Reputation
-2,378
Daps
47,064
Reppin
NULL
Truefan31 said:
I’ve been watching the nfl for a long time. Lots of qbs over the years.

mahomes is unlike any of them. The nfl is a different game now I get it. But mahomes has a special arm. And he’s bigger and more athletic than Rodgers. What’s scary is that this is only his 3rd real year playing.

this year so far 3500 yards, 30 tds and 2 ints. Smh...

Career 106 tds with only 20 ints is absurd and nobody else is close in that stat.
Click to expand...

hes not bigger then Rodgers ive seen him in person he’s much shorter then I thought.

He’s got the best TE and most dangerous wr in the game along with a historically good playcaller in Reid

also you can’t just go by numbers since this is by far the easiest era to throw in. Mediocre Qbs from this era will heve better numbers then great Qbs from the past

Hes great and maybe the Goat when it’s all said and done but it’s unfair to say Rodgers isn’t in the discussion with him
 
Piff Perkins

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
53,470
Reputation
19,954
Daps
292,648
Obviously Brady is near/at the end so it's not the most fair comparison but man...watching that game was night and day. The command Mahomes has, the variety of throws, the way he just effortlessly leads his team down the field. Just a few weeks ago people were claiming he got exposed, zones can confuse him etc etc. Naaah.

Rodgers is sill #1 to me but like I said, it's obvious Mahomes is going to be the number one when all is said and done. Anything can happen in the playoffs but brehs...who is stopping KC?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top