28 Gramz
How U Luv That???
It's becoming harder to argue this every year 
Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen?
- Thread starter 28 Gramz
- Start date
No it’s still Brady. But if Mahomes wins 3 then we can start having that conversation.
If they beat the Eagles he’s already top 10 all time in my book. He might be the most talented QB. But greatest career is still Brady.
If they beat the Eagles he’s already top 10 all time in my book. He might be the most talented QB. But greatest career is still Brady.
Vandelay
Life is absurd. Lean into it.
Without a doubt. He's in that pantheon only after 5 years. Unless his career ends in the next 2 years, not sure how he's not in everyone's top 5 all-time. He's gotta be in the top 5 not only because of the ridiculous stat lines, but the ridiculous feats, and most of all he wins. Those are the categories that justify greatness to me; stats, feats, wins...Mahomes has all 3 in great number in 5 years.
Pat and Brady have gone on record saying they talk regularly and Brady gives him advice. Brady isn’t doing that for any other QB
It's definitely still Brady. He also has shown us that QB isn't a position that is even really about physical ability or talent, it's all mental and intangibles.
In terms of pure arm talent Mahomes isn't the most talented either. It's Aaron Rodgers.
Mahomes with 3 is definitely the conversation starter, but as of now not yet.
Brian O'Conner
All Star
The way he was fired up on the sidelines screaming at coaches and then limped onto the field to win the game was impressive 
Vandelay
Life is absurd. Lean into it.
What's wilder is, Brady is one of the GOATs, but even with the 3 superbowl wins...he didn't really show GOAT status until Moss showed up in what; year 8?. Mahomes is showing that without any equivalent receivers. By year 2, you knew he was something different.
By himself, Mahomes is like a hybrid Dan Marino and Steve Young to me.
Tom is the GOAT QB....but this Pat shyt is ....dunno what to even call it.
All facts!!!
28 Gramz
How U Luv That???
Mahomes arm talent is better than Rodgers to me. I've never seen Rodgers do a 360 spin pass or a no look hook shot pass, the things he can do with the ball has never been seen.
This is a myth. Brady was in best QB conversations around 2004-05, he was great in the Superbowls vs the Eagles and Panthers.
As of now, it's Brady.
However, Mahomes can absolutely get there. He won't need seven Super Bowls. He'll need at least two more and then more MVP's, but he has the talent, time, and accolades to make it happen.
However, Mahomes can absolutely get there. He won't need seven Super Bowls. He'll need at least two more and then more MVP's, but he has the talent, time, and accolades to make it happen.
Yes hes the best QB I've ever seen play....
Hes out there with shyt WRs, cast off RBs, and a double covered HOF TE and produces one of the best offenses in the league. He doesnt have the resume of Brady, and probably nobody will. But from a pure talent standpoint this dude is ridiculous
Hes out there with shyt WRs, cast off RBs, and a double covered HOF TE and produces one of the best offenses in the league. He doesnt have the resume of Brady, and probably nobody will. But from a pure talent standpoint this dude is ridiculous
skyrunner1
Superstar
Brady was a game manager at same time of their career.. Manning was still thought of as better qb and it didnt really flip til Moss and Welker team where Brady became a passing beast.. Also even when he had more titles than Manning it was still argument because titles didnt become end all till next decade for Lebron mj debate type stuff..
The pace and what he is doing this early in his career is incredible. Never seen anything like it, and to think if a DE wasnt offside he would start his career going to this many super bowls, its insane.. I dont think rings determine if you can have the convo, convo is already being had.. The rings will just seal the deal. He is already at the table in just a few years