My only knock on Rodgers is unlike Pat and Brady who fight for their teams with not only their talent but their hunger to win and leadership he’ll bytch and throw you under the bus
Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen?
- Thread starter 28 Gramz
- Start date
My only knock on Rodgers is unlike Pat and Brady who fight for their teams with not only their talent but their hunger to win and leadership he’ll bytch and throw you under the bus
Vandelay
Life is absurd. Lean into it.
It was speculation, it wasn't unanimous. Brady was being brought up, true...but people would also bring up Terry Bradshaw had a gang of wins too. Statistically, Brady wasn't top 5 anything his first 5-6 years...you just had to bring him up because he won 3 championships.
He just won...not discounting that, but Troy Aikman "just won" too. Statistically Aikman wasn't a beast nor is he top 10 QB's either, but he skirted the conversation because you can't deny 3 superbowl wins.
It was a different conversation prior to Moss. A speculation conversation...People before Moss brought up the Tuck rule and he only won by 3 on the backs of his defense prior to Moss. Once Moss got there, then Welker, then Hernandez and Gronk, people started saying Brady was an undisputed GOAT.
Last edited:
Aaron's ball placement and accuracy was better, threw better on the run, threw deep balls with pinpoint accuracy in the bucket, but you're right about him not throwing trick passes or those sidearms. I don't know if that's considered pure arm talent per se
David_TheMan
Veteran
I've seen Marino and Montana.
So no
So no
I think it's just how crazy some of these throws and plays he's making are. It's next to impossible to say he's the greatest ever yet. But I sure as shyt can say he's made some of the batshyt craziest, how in the fukk did that happen ass plays I can remember seeing.
PortCityProphet
Follow me to the truth
Pure QB yep
Jalen Hurts prolly gonna catch him in bout 3 years then Bryce Young in 5 tho
Brian O'Conner
All Star
So Tom Brady is playing the Jordan role to Mahomes Kobe? 
He’s better than Rodgers. Rodgers stay underachieving. He’s only been to 1 SB all those years……….
He’s better than Marino. I’ll give respect to Montana because he was the coolest cat ever in pressure moments……..
Rocket Scientist
Superstar
Rodgers was launching hail marys back in the day. Every QB can throw or have poise but Maholmes is different man.Hes like the Golden Child QB or something .
28 Gramz
How U Luv That???
So Tom Brady is playing the Jordan role to Mahomes Kobe?
No. Kobe is my fav player but was never on Mike's prime level even at his best. Mahomes right now is better than Brady was in his prime so he's on pace to pass him up.
28 Gramz
How U Luv That???
Steph was never the best player in the league, even in 2016.
J Money
No weapon formed against me shall prosper
This isn't the NBA I don't care about team accolades. He has underperformed but I'm talking just pure QB skill