Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen?

[Chip Skylark]

Thats a myth about Rodger Rodgers want to win just as bad
T

Lol sure

 

[Trojan 24]

Give me one QB to pick as my starter from all-time and I'm going with Mahomes, but your can't deny Brady as the GOAT. QB is intrinsically tied to team performance and accolades, Brady has that and everything else in spades. Mahomey gonna need to get at least 4 chips to enter the discussion

 

[Trojan 24]

Brady is 7-3 in SB. 10 SB appearances. 3 rings? that's cute. Let's not forget, Brady could've gone to 2 more SBs in 2006 and 2021. don't forget we were robbed of Brady's absolute peak in 2008 with an injury.

Road to being top 5 is very simple. keep dominating and win a SB or two. He will get there.

but road to being the GOAT? almost impossible.


and no matter what happens, brady can still claim he beat mahomes twice in the playoffs.

Folks tried to clown Kellerman for saying GOAT status could possibly be on the line when they squared off, but he was right. Mahomes wins that bowl, Brady stays at 6 and he has a chance to get to 3 this year. 5 wouldn't seem too far off and he won the head to head. Instead it's 7 to 1 and seemingly impossible to close that gap

 

[JYoung24]

So Tom Brady is playing the Jordan role to Mahomes Kobe?

Steph was never the best player in the league, even in 2016.

Yes he was

 

[Biscayne]

Brady is 7-3 in SB. 10 SB appearances. 3 rings? that's cute. Let's not forget, Brady could've gone to 2 more SBs in 2006 and 2021. don't forget we were robbed of Brady's absolute peak in 2008 with an injury.

Road to being top 5 is very simple. keep dominating and win a SB or two. He will get there.

but road to being the GOAT? almost impossible.


and no matter what happens, brady can still claim he beat mahomes twice in the playoffs.

Brady’s the current goat as it stands. But there ain’t no “no matter what”. Nah, if he ties Brady’s ring totals and or beats them, then there’s no way Mahomes won’t be the goat. He’ll be undisputed goat. No matter how many times Brady beat him head to head. This ain’t basketball. Mahomes post season stats says it all.

 

[FabTrey]

Brady’s the current goat as it stands. But there ain’t no “no matter what”. Nah, if he ties Brady’s ring totals and or beats them, then there’s no way Mahomes won’t be the goat. He’ll be undisputed goat. No matter how many times Brady beat him head to head. This ain’t basketball. Mahomes post season stats says it all.

Sample sizes breh. Things can turn sour real quick. You can't crown anybody after 5 years. Ask Rodgers. The entire media crowned him as 'the best ever seen', 'the bad man'. A decade later that perception is gone.

Margin for error is tiny. If mahomes loses to eagles and he looks clueless like how he looked against the bucs then the narrative will quickly change.

 

[murksiderock]

Sample sizes breh. Things can turn sour real quick. You can't crown anybody after 5 years. Ask Rodgers. The entire media crowned him as 'the best ever seen', 'the bad man'. A decade later that perception is gone.

Margin for error is tiny. If mahomes loses to eagles and he looks clueless like how he looked against the bucs then the narrative will quickly change.

Bro they know this. It's just en vogue around here to pretend Mahomes is the first quarterback we've heard called "the most talented quarterback ever". Dudes wanna crown dudes off "talent" so bad...

 

[Cave Savage]

Sample sizes breh. Things can turn sour real quick. You can't crown anybody after 5 years. Ask Rodgers. The entire media crowned him as 'the best ever seen', 'the bad man'. A decade later that perception is gone.

Margin for error is tiny. If mahomes loses to eagles and he looks clueless like how he looked against the bucs then the narrative will quickly change.

It also seems considerably harder in football to even get multiple rings (perhaps due to the one and done playoffs)

 

[Killer Instinct]

Mahomes could never win another SB & he is still, bar none, the most talented QB I've ever seen. How much he'll build on and enhance that aspect via individual & team accolades is the only thing in question. Barring a severe injury or a case of the yips, he'll be a pantheon great and a top #3 QB all time at worse once the curtains close on his career if he continues to perform at this level for another 5 - 7 years.

 

[JYoung24]

Completely agree.

The 2 Superbowls during Brady's Prime had him losing to the Giants. Crazy. His best years IMO was the gap in between.

Before Pat, ARod talent wise was the best I saw with my eyes, but he consistently came up short. Pat hasn't.

He didn't come up short his team did

 

[JYoung24]

Rodgers has some of the worst meltdowns in big games. Especially last year, Rodgers basically doing nothing in a home playoff game. Mahomes is more talented than Rodgers anyway.

Rodgers has lost most of the time because of his defense other than last I can't call them meltdowns Brady was never beating my 49ers team in either year

 

[JYoung24]

Brady is the GOAT. But before Mahommes Manning was the best QB I had ever seen untill the playoffs where he kept choking and losing to Beli and Brady. Honestly until Yesterday, I thought that Burrow and Mahommes was going to go ala Brady and Manning where one is clearly the better player but the other team just has their number.

We got to stop with this Manning choking in the playoffs narrative and Manning has a winning record against Brady in the playoffs

 

[Rekkapryde]

He didn't come up short his team did

I don't necessarily disagree but he has laid some duds himself. Last year was bad. That was him.

 

[VegetasHairline]

We got to stop with this Manning choking in the playoffs narrative and Manning has a winning record against Brady in the playoffs

It's not a narrative. It actually happened!

 

[JYoung24]

No he won't. Championships matter. He may break Brady's records but he won't sniff his Superbowls. Because of that, and the fact Brady won it all with 2 different teams, Brady will remain the goat far after Patrick hangs it up

Nah maholmes doesn't need 7 rings to be the goat