Is Reasonable Doubt the consensus GOAT hip hop album?

[Not Crodie]

haven't listened to it since "97

 

[Diunx]

 

[Bondye Vodou]

 

[Not Crodie]

there's like 3 good songs on it lol

 

[Sausageman]

Reasonable doubt is not GRODT op

 

[BulletProof]

A few songs made my iPod.

 

[Bolzmark]

GOAT no, classic of course, maybe top 5, unquestionably top 10 all time.

 

[b@squ1@t]

everybody knows the makaveli album is the GOAT

 

[mrken12]

this is completely false. It got more burn than the following in streets:

Ironman
Hell On earth
Muddy Waters
Wrath Of The Math



I was there. You can't lie to me like you do these feeble posters. Album was the choice of any and every dude involved even peripherally in street life.

What about Ridin Dirty?

 

[Big Mel]

What about Ridin Dirty?

Aside from Jay Z, not many NYers gave a shyt about UGK.

 

[Nuuko]

illmatic.

rd isn't even top 100

 

[Big Mel]

^^^^lies

 

[Homeboy Runny-Ray]

@Big Mel kickin over these kids' toy forts in here.

lol @ "ridin dirty".

***pulls up a chair and ***

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

Aside from Jay Z, not many NYers gave a shyt about UGK.

And as a southerner, not too many of us gave a fukk about Jay-Z. We fukked with purple tape, AZ, ATLiens, etc much more. You had your wanna be different nikkas who bumped it (even I was a fan of Can't Knock the Hustle) but for some to claim it was this universally loved album is completely false. Foxy's "Ill NaNa" got more burn/love than RD if we gonna keep it all the way funky. As I've said before, RD was what Eightball & MJGs "Comin Out Hard" was to southern nikkas, a local classic

 

[Big Mel]

And as a southerner, not too many of us gave a fukk about Jay-Z. We fukked with purple tape, AZ, ATLiens, etc much more. You had your wanna be different nikkas who bumped it (even I was a fan of Can't Knock the Hustle) but for some to claim it was this universally loved album is completely false. Foxy's "I'll NaNa" got more burn/love than RD if we gonna keep it all the way funky. As I've said before, RD was what Eightball & MJGs "Comin Out Hard" was to southern nikkas, a local classic

I'm having a real hard time imagining AZ getting more burn than Jay. Like a REAL hard time. Seems you may be semi Nas stanning with the AZ/Cuban Link inclusion.


And I'm speaking strictly for New York, the most important place in hip hop in 1996. What a guy below the mason Dixon played is of little importance to me. You guys weren't playing Illmatic rabidly either.