Jay Z & Nas - Black Republican...who won?

Who had the better verse?


  • Total voters
    81

Robbie3000

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
32,305
Reputation
6,390
Daps
144,146
Reppin
NULL
I'm a die hard Nas fan, but Camel got him slightly on this song. Only by the slightest of margins though. By the sound of Jay-Z during the intro, you could tell he spent a lot of time and effort on his verse because he was so happy to finally be on a song with his rap hero.

He admitted he was about to start tap dancing in the studio cause he was in the same booth as the GOAT. Jay was probably doing cartwheels and shyt while Nas was just ehh, this is just another song from a storied career.

So Nas still won.
 

erker

All Star
Joined
Jul 9, 2012
Messages
3,308
Reputation
845
Daps
8,722
Reppin
The Netherlands
Jay's verse started off a lil erratic but was better.I believe nas was intimidated that the guy who publicly humiliated him was on his album and song his verse was basic and sub par

Jay murdered nas on his own shyt.Dope song

:snoop:

Obvious troll is obvious

You still mad Jay :sadbron: lost? That Ether still burns

*plays "Burn baby burn"*
 

AkaDemiK

I Love Hip-Hop
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
42,237
Reputation
6,201
Daps
106,512
Nas went the fukk in..

I'm standin' on the roof of my building
I'm feelin' - the whirlwind of beef, I inhale it
Just like an acrobat ready to hurl myself through the hoops of fire
Sippin' 80 proof, bulletproof under my attire

>>>>>>>>>>>
 

Larry

...
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
15,028
Reputation
3,197
Daps
51,337
there aint no way Nas verse was better :russ: :laff:


you gotta really be a nas stan or hate Jay-Z to even say that shyt. Nas is a billion times the rapper Jay-Z has ever been, I truly believe that. Nas is just nicer than Jay. Period. BUT ON THIS TRACk...THIS TRACK..no way did Nas body Jay-Z :laff: like get outta here


dont get it twisted, Jay didn't body Nas either :mjpls: a body wasnt caught by anyone on this track, but Jay verse obviously tops Nas'.
 

the rhyme king

truth.com
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
7,235
Reputation
-1,651
Daps
3,062
Reppin
i refuse to conform
there aint no way Nas verse was better :russ: :laff:


you gotta really be a nas stan or hate Jay-Z to even say that shyt. Nas is a billion times the rapper Jay-Z has ever been, I truly believe that. Nas is just nicer than Jay. Period. BUT ON THIS TRACk...THIS TRACK..no way did Nas body Jay-Z :laff: like get outta here


dont get it twisted, Jay didn't body Nas either :mjpls: a body wasnt caught by anyone on this track, but Jay verse obviously tops Nas'.


nas murked jigga on this shyt

the rhyme scheme was complicated

I'm back in the hood, they like, "Hey Nas" (Uh)
Blowin' on purp', reflectin' on they lives
Couple of fat cats, couple of A.I.'s
Dreamin' of fly shyt instead of them gray skies
Gray 5's, hate guys wishin' our reign dies
Pitch, sling pies, and nikkas they sing, "why"?
Guess they ain't strong enough to handle their jail time
Weak minds, keep tryin', follow the street signs
I'm standin' on the roof of my building
I'm feelin' - the whirlwind of beef, I inhale it
Just like an acrobat ready to hurl myself though the hoops of fire
Sippin' 80 proof, bulletproof under my attire
Could it be the forces of darkness, against hood angels of good
That forms street politics - makes a sweet honest kid
Turn illegal for commerce - to get his feet out of them Converse
That's my word

the rhyme scheme was ridiculous
 

prophecypro

Hollywood North
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
28,998
Reputation
2,988
Daps
62,652
Reppin
LDN
there aint no way Nas verse was better :russ: :laff:


you gotta really be a nas stan or hate Jay-Z to even say that shyt. Nas is a billion times the rapper Jay-Z has ever been, I truly believe that. Nas is just nicer than Jay. Period. BUT ON THIS TRACk...THIS TRACK..no way did Nas body Jay-Z :laff: like get outta here


dont get it twisted, Jay didn't body Nas either :mjpls: a body wasnt caught by anyone on this track, but Jay verse obviously tops Nas'.

To me it just seemed like Jay was talking about someone else on the record and it was like he had that verse for like Dame or a former partner, seemed kinda different fitting on that track. Same token though people can say that about Nas verse on Success
 

blackslash

Superstar
Bushed
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
17,946
Reputation
-1,985
Daps
25,313
What makes Jay's verse stand out more to you? My thing is it seemed like he was rapping on a subject matter that was different to theme of the track. Like when I heard it I was like "Is this some metaphor for his relationship with Dame? Cause he was talking about someone?" and it kinda went on and on.

That and it paints a vivid picture of the politics of the street and gives you the motivation of what tears up the relationship he has. Jay very strongly shows the power of money in his verse and what that thats what turns him into the "villain" or the black republican...which then sets us up for

"the black militant" of the song whiich is where Nas comes in in which they were once on the same side but according to Jay's verse jealousy and envy has caused him want to "take over the govt" and money has caused Jay to become obsessed with power


Thats how I look at it anyways :manny:
 

DStyles

Vegan
Joined
Jun 2, 2012
Messages
8,740
Reputation
-4,121
Daps
9,539
Reppin
Brooklyn,NY/Manchester,UK
Jay had more presence on the track and rapped a little longer.. its a tie.


I remember hearing that track for the first time..the godfather sample had me like :blessed: :blessed:

nobody got bodied..it was/is a win for hip hop..and it would be an ever bigger win if they dropped a full album together.

Nah

Then you would have multiple threads of dikkriding over who had the better verses

I wouldn't be able to live with that :snoop:
 

erker

All Star
Joined
Jul 9, 2012
Messages
3,308
Reputation
845
Daps
8,722
Reppin
The Netherlands
That "diss" filled with nothing but elementary jokes? :comeon::rudy::mjpls::childplease:

I didn't want to bring this up, but you left me no choice:
[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffDDbEJAEIg&playnext=1&list=PL4305205A44E8B980&feature=results_video][AUDIO] Jay-Z Crying On Hot97 After Hearing Ether!! Nas WON - YouTube[/ame]
 

prophecypro

Hollywood North
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
28,998
Reputation
2,988
Daps
62,652
Reppin
LDN
That and it paints a vivid picture of the politics of the street and gives you the motivation of what tears up the relationship he has. Jay very strongly shows the power of money in his verse and what that thats what turns him into the "villain" or the black republican...which then sets us up for

"the black militant" of the song whiich is where Nas comes in in which they were once on the same side but according to Jay's verse jealousy and envy has caused him want to "take over the govt" and money has caused Jay to become obsessed with power


Thats how I look at it anyways :manny:

I was with you until you tried to make it seem like Nas was the villian on his own song lol
 

blackslash

Superstar
Bushed
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
17,946
Reputation
-1,985
Daps
25,313
I was with you until you tried to make it seem like Nas was the villian on his own song lol

Well he's not...he's the "good guy" the rebel against the corrupt black republican


Anyway I feel Jay's verse was perfect rhyme scheme wise, flow wise, the delivery was ehh, but the storytelling in his verse was great..Idk I jus feel theres more good in Jay's verse than in Nas'
 
Top