Jed counts the M's, while the team holds the L's: Official 49ers 2016 Season Thread

Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
24,795
Reputation
-4,700
Daps
19,006
@yseJ @thatknickfan @Rekkapryde @FaTaL and all others

Let's play a game, keep 5 release 5. Out of these 10 guys, which do you keep, which do you get rid of if you're GM.

Carlos Hyde
Ahmad Brooks
Torrey Smith
Eric Reid
Jeremy Kerley
Mike Davis
Trumaine Brock
DuJuan Harris
Colin Kaepernick
Antoine Bathea

Keep
Kerley, Reid, Brock. Harris, Brooks

Get rid of
Davis, Smith, Bathea, Hyde, Kaepernick
 

B90X

All Star
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
3,847
Reputation
140
Daps
5,417
Reppin
NINER EMPIRE
Armstead is a de and right now there's no way we get garrett

I'd be good with Garrett or Barnett from Tennessee, especially if we're seriously going to move from a 3-4 to a 4-3. Barnett is about to break Reggie White's all time sack record at Tennessee. I'm not saying he's going to be the same type of player as Reggie White, but breaking his sack record means something. I believe the record is 32 sacks and he's at 30.
 

Robbo

All Star
Joined
Mar 27, 2015
Messages
2,354
Reputation
780
Daps
6,199
@yseJ @thatknickfan @Rekkapryde @FaTaL and all others

Let's play a game, keep 5 release 5. Out of these 10 guys, which do you keep, which do you get rid of if you're GM.

Carlos Hyde
Ahmad Brooks
Torrey Smith
Eric Reid
Jeremy Kerley
Mike Davis
Trumaine Brock
DuJuan Harris
Colin Kaepernick
Antoine Bathea
Keep
Brooks, Brock, Kaepernick (even though they won't), Hyde, Reid

Brooks is still useful when he's engaged. Brock can be a solid corner in the rotation. Kaepernick has showed some ability to move the offense, we need to upgrade the position, but for now, i like what he's doing. Hyde i'm not sold on, but i'd like to see the line improve and then see how he operates. He dances too much behind the line, but the defense is always in the backfield. Reid is just a more solid placeholder than Bethea, i'm still disappointed with his progression.

Get rid of
Smith, Kerley, Davis, Harris, Bethea

I like what Kerley has done, but if we actually upgrade the position, we don't have as much use for him. Davis is more of a split carries type of back. Harris has bounced around for a reason. I like Bethea's tenacity, but he's just getting old at this point.
 

FaTaL

Veteran
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
106,519
Reputation
5,479
Daps
212,243
Reppin
NULL
@yseJ @thatknickfan @Rekkapryde @FaTaL and all others

Let's play a game, keep 5 release 5. Out of these 10 guys, which do you keep, which do you get rid of if you're GM.

Carlos Hyde
Ahmad Brooks
Torrey Smith
Eric Reid
Jeremy Kerley
Mike Davis
Trumaine Brock
DuJuan Harris
Colin Kaepernick
Antoine Bathea

Keep
Kerley, Reid, Brock. Harris, Brooks

Get rid of
Davis, Smith, Bathea, Hyde, Kaepernick

Hyde
Reid
Kerly
Harris
Kaep

Unless we draft a qb ready to step in we gotta keep Kaep
 

Khross

Pro
Joined
Jul 27, 2012
Messages
693
Reputation
290
Daps
2,401
Reppin
NULL
This. I think that's the problem with him. He's a strong safety

I think after the concussions they kinda pulled back from the Reid at SS thought line. Thats just me talking out my ass though im just saying homie kinda seemed prone for awhile
 

Robbo

All Star
Joined
Mar 27, 2015
Messages
2,354
Reputation
780
Daps
6,199
Is there anything to be said about Armstead being out and the run defense being much better

Who started at end? was it Dial? I'm sure that was a contributing factor, plus Brooks and Harold seemed to set the edge pretty well.
 
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
24,795
Reputation
-4,700
Daps
19,006
Hyde
Reid
Kerly
Harris
Kaep

Unless we draft a qb ready to step in we gotta keep Kaep

I like the progress from Kaep, but i`m thinking money wise in a complete rebuild where we probably draft a qb or bring one in, Kaep makes little sense.

He was the last guy on my bubble though
 
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
24,795
Reputation
-4,700
Daps
19,006
Who started at end? was it Dial? I'm sure that was a contributing factor, plus Brooks and Harold seemed to set the edge pretty well.

Armstead and Bucker were both known to be bad against the rush this season, Armsteads gone an all of a sudden we shut down David Johnson? The rest of the year will be interesting
 

Robbo

All Star
Joined
Mar 27, 2015
Messages
2,354
Reputation
780
Daps
6,199
Armstead and Bucker were both known to be bad against the rush this season, Armsteads gone an all of a sudden we shut down David Johnson? The rest of the year will be interesting

If anything it may help get a better rotation on the D Line. If this defense can stop the run at all, they can be solid. We need help at LB obviously, but I don't hate our secondary.
 
Top