Karl Malone or Tim Duncan?

[Miggs]

I'll listen to the Malone argument. Just like I'll listen to, say, a Ewing or a Robinson over Dream argument, but in the end Timmy>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Mailman.

It just is what it is...

Theres no case to be made for Ewing over Hakeem...

 

[360Waves]

Do you understand the concept of defense?

Pretend that Malone wouldn't have David Robinson by his side for 2 rings.

Pretend the Spurs didn't always have depth and talent at every position to help out.

What Malone lacks in defensive ability he makes up for by being 2 times the scorer Duncan is.

 

[I.AM.PIFF]

Dirk/Chuck & Karl is a better comparison

I'd take Karl over Barkley easily, but IDK about Dirk

 

[DrexlersFade]

Pretend that Malone wouldn't have David Robinson by his side for 2 rings.

Pretend the Spurs didn't always have depth and talent at every position to help out.

What Malone lacks in defensive ability he makes up for by being 2 times the scorer Duncan is.

Yeah cause that 03 was so stacked right
34 Mengke Bateer C 6-11 290 November 20, 1975 1
12 Bruce Bowen SF 6-7 185 June 14, 1971 6 California State University, Fullerton
23 Devin Brown SG 6-5 220 December 30, 1978 R University of Texas at San Antonio
10 Speedy Claxton PG 5-11 166 May 8, 1978 1 Hofstra University
21 Tim Duncan PF 6-11 248 April 25, 1976 5 Wake Forest University
35 Danny Ferry SF 6-10 230 October 17, 1966 12 Duke University
20 Manu Ginobili SG 6-6 210 July 28, 1977 R
5 Anthony Goldwire PG 6-1 182 September 6, 1971 4 University of Houston
3 Stephen Jackson SG 6-8 218 April 5, 1978 2 Butler County Community College
25 Steve Kerr PG 6-3 175 September 27, 1965 14 University of Arizona
9 Tony Parker PG 6-2 180 May 17, 1982 1
50 David Robinson C 7-1 235 August 6, 1965 13 United States Naval Academy
31 Malik Rose PF 6-7 250 November 23, 1974 6 Drexel University
8 Steve Smith SG 6-7 200 March 31, 1969 11 Michigan State University
42 Kevin Willis

2005 squad
17Brent BarrySG6-6185December 31, 19719Oregon State University
12Bruce BowenSF6-7185June 14, 19718California State University, Fullerton
23Devin BrownSG6-5220December 30, 19782University of Texas at San Antonio
21Tim DuncanPF6-11248April 25, 19767Wake Forest University
20Manu GinobiliSG6-6210July 28, 1977
21Dion GloverSG6-5228October 22, 1978Georgia Institute of Technology
5Robert HorryPF6-9220August 25, 197012University of Alabama
43Linton JohnsonSF6-8205June 13, 19801Tulane University
4Sean MarksPF6-10250August 23, 19754University of California
34Tony MassenburgPF6-9220July 31, 196712University of Maryland
2Nazr MohammedC6-10221September 5, 19776University of Kentucky
8Rasho NesterovicC7-0248May 30, 19766
9Tony ParkerPG6-2180May 17, 1982
33Glenn RobinsonSF6-7225January 10, 197310Purdue University
31Malik RosePF6-7250November 23, 19748Drexel University
14Beno UdrihPG6-3205July 5, 1982R
11Mike WilksPG5-10185May 7, 19792Rice University

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Pretend that Malone wouldn't have David Robinson by his side for 2 rings.

Pretend the Spurs didn't always have depth and talent at every position to help out.

What Malone lacks in defensive ability he makes up for by being 2 times the scorer Duncan is.

You don't even know what you're talking about.

 

[I.AM.PIFF]

34 Mengke Bateer C 6-11 290 November 20, 1975 1

I completely forgot about the Chinese giant

 

[360Waves]

Yeah cause that 03 was so stacked right
34 Mengke Bateer C 6-11 290 November 20, 1975 1
12 Bruce Bowen SF 6-7 185 June 14, 1971 6 California State University, Fullerton
23 Devin Brown SG 6-5 220 December 30, 1978 R University of Texas at San Antonio
10 Speedy Claxton PG 5-11 166 May 8, 1978 1 Hofstra University
21 Tim Duncan PF 6-11 248 April 25, 1976 5 Wake Forest University
35 Danny Ferry SF 6-10 230 October 17, 1966 12 Duke University
20 Manu Ginobili SG 6-6 210 July 28, 1977 R
5 Anthony Goldwire PG 6-1 182 September 6, 1971 4 University of Houston
3 Stephen Jackson SG 6-8 218 April 5, 1978 2 Butler County Community College
25 Steve Kerr PG 6-3 175 September 27, 1965 14 University of Arizona
9 Tony Parker PG 6-2 180 May 17, 1982 1
50 David Robinson C 7-1 235 August 6, 1965 13 United States Naval Academy
31 Malik Rose PF 6-7 250 November 23, 1974 6 Drexel University
8 Steve Smith SG 6-7 200 March 31, 1969 11 Michigan State University
42 Kevin Willis

But they had David Robinson, who would've served as an excellent defensive 5 to mask Malone's inabilities on that end, a la Tyson Chandler for Dirk.

Think of it this way..

99-Robison's there
2003-Robinson's there
2005-The only toss up.
2007-Didn't need any kind of defense to beat that ass Cavs team.
2014-Team was loaded with depth.

Genuinely think that if Malone was replaced with Tim Duncan but everything else stayed the same, the outcomes of those Finals would all still end up in SA victories. The ONLY toss up would be with that Detroit team in 2007, but even with Duncan that shyt went to 7 so...

 

[GPBear]

Duncan was a center playing power forward, that homo Malone was an actual power forward. I'll take Duncan because of defense in the paint. That's all.

Im takin Malone because this homo called Karl a homo


aint no fakkit

 

[DrexlersFade]

But they had David Robinson, who would've served as an excellent defensive 5 to mask Malone's inabilities on that end, a la Tyson Chandler for Dirk.

Think of it this way..

99-Robison's there
2003-Robinson's there
2005-The only toss up.
2007-Didn't need any kind of defense to beat that ass Cavs team.
2014-Team was loaded with depth.

Genuinely think that if Malone was replaced with Tim Duncan but everything else stayed the same, the outcomes of those Finals would all still end up in SA victories. The ONLY toss up would be with that Detroit team in 2007, but even with Duncan that shyt went to 7 so...

Robinson was on one leg by the time 03 came and he was never the same after his achilles...Malone was a fukking hog who bogged down the Jazz offense...


Nigags talking about Malone was two time the offense of player foh Malone couldn't fukking shoot a 5footer until about 93,nikkas be disrespecting Tim offensive game it was nothing he couldn't do in his prime no weaknesses nikka wtf you thought

 

[360Waves]

Robinson was on one leg by the time 03 came and he was never the same after his achilles...Malone was a fukking hog who bogged down the Jazz offense...


Nigags talking about Malone was two time the offense of player foh Malone couldn't fukking shoot a 5footer until about 93,nikkas be disrespecting Tim offensive game it was nothing he couldn't do in his prime no weaknesses nikka wtf you thought

Uh, he was still a big contributor in '99 and while he was in '03 he was still a starter giving you 2 blocks per game and a nice interior presence defensively--which at the time, was all they needed him to do. You're acting like I said Robinson would be there to contribute with the scoring load as well but I very specifically stated that Malone as a defensive liability would not matter because Robinson was there. That was it.

 

[BXKingPin82]

who the fukk didnt pick Tim Duncan?
do i have to start returning to doing parlor tricks like coming thru phone and computer screens?

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

But they had David Robinson, who would've served as an excellent defensive 5 to mask Malone's inabilities on that end, a la Tyson Chandler for Dirk.

Think of it this way..

99-Robison's there
2003-Robinson's there
2005-The only toss up.
2007-Didn't need any kind of defense to beat that ass Cavs team.
2014-Team was loaded with depth.

Genuinely think that if Malone was replaced with Tim Duncan but everything else stayed the same, the outcomes of those Finals would all still end up in SA victories. The ONLY toss up would be with that Detroit team in 2007, but even with Duncan that shyt went to 7 so...

You obviously didn't watch the Spurs in 2003.

 

[daboywonder2002]

malone if you want scoring. its not too many pfs that can average 30 in their sleep. malone could do it all. post up. mid range. 15-18 footer wet as hell. get to the line and actually hit his free throws. but duncan was the better rebounder, shot blocker and all around defender. offense- malone. defense- duncan

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Uh, he was still a big contributor in '99 and while he was in '03 he was still a starter giving you 2 blocks per game and a nice interior presence defensively--which at the time, was all they needed him to do. You're acting like I said Robinson would be there to contribute with the scoring load as well but I very specifically stated that Malone as a defensive liability would not matter because Robinson was there. That was it.

Yeah let's just ignore the fact that Duncan was the defensive anchor during the 2002/2003 season and averaged 3.3 blocks per game in the playoffs.

 

[TheNig]

Kobe.