Mahomes is top-4 all time

[Still Benefited]

If he gets 5 rings by his mid 30s I could see that argument, but 2 is not enough

One thing we know is that the Patriots cheated to get at least 3 of those rings. If something seems impossible,like going to the superbowl and winning that many times. It probably is impossible,unless your cheating of course

 

[RickyDiBiase]

4-5 rings???

He passed Rodgers, Young, L-Way, Brees, Staubach, Favre, Marino already

Only Montana and Brady are clearly above him

Oh he’s surpassing Montana easily

 

[Ain't That Something]

He was more dominant than anybody in the regular season tho

His 2013 was the magnus opus of Quarterbacking

I don;t remember the seaswon, but that one season where he had that QB battale against the chiefs was the best I think he ever played. 2004 i think. I legit believe breh was going to go all the way that season. He let me down so many times

 

[The_Unchosen_One]

Only Brady, the Sheriff, and Montana were better



2 Rings
2 SB MVPs
2 regular season MVPs

And Pat just getting started

 

[BrehWyatt]

We haven’t seen anyone play QB better. It’s that simple.

Mahomes is the most prolific talent we've seen at the position. Only Rodgers has an argument to the contrary.

But as far as playing and mastering the position of quarterback (i.e. game control), Brady, Peyton Manning and perhaps even Drew Brees have for sure done that better than him at some point in their careers.

 

[Chip Skylark]

Mahomes is the new Dan Marino

Marino never won a ring! What are you saying

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

Tom Brady in 2021:

5,316 yds, 67.5 cmp%, 45 TDs, 12 INTs, 102.1 passer rating. 15th rushing off. Tied for best record in NFC.

Patrick Mahomes this yr:

5,250 yds, 67.1 cmp%, 45 TDs, 12 INTs, 105.1 passer rating, 8th rushing off. Best record.

So Brady with Gronk, Mike Evans and Chris Godwin as his top 3 targets.
Vs Mahomes with Kelce, JuJu and MVS as his top 3 targets.


You didn't mention that Brady threw it 719 times to achieve this, while Mahomes only threw it 648 times. Better Y/A and QB rating for Mahomes.

edit: pointing out that KC had a higher ranked run game is weird, considering Mahomes added 358 rush yards himself, compared to Brady's 81.

I'm taking Mahomes season and I think he'd feast playing on the 2021 Bucs.

 

[skyrunner1]

Only Brady, the Sheriff, and Montana were better



2 Rings
2 SB MVPs
2 regular season MVPs

Don't forget he turned the super bowl to the Mahomes invitational

 

[br82186]

We saw Andy Reid for nearly 20 years before Mahomes became the starter.

And Reid never got the job done with those teams pre Mahomes

 

[Trojan 24]

The one who who had a costly turnover?

And threw two other ducks that should have been picked off

 

[ThiefyPoo]

@Basaglia
@NV-ME
@KBadd

 

[skyrunner1]

Nah

7 >>>> 2

And he already lost to Brady

He COMIN

 

[Trojan 24]

If he gets to 4 we can start the conversation

 

[Soldier]

He got the same arm and the same great passing ability. The same passing accuracy.
The same vision and game management

Marino never won a ring?!?! What are you saying

I know he never won a super bowl ring but see my post above, I’m talking about talent not rings

 

[skyrunner1]

If he gets to 4 we can start the conversation

He played on broken ankle.. looked like he bust a nut on sideline and impregnated riri before halftime.. that's worth a couple rings right there alone