Mahomes is top-4 all time
- Thread starter BlueHeffner
- Start date
No it wasn’t. He was doing a lot of stat padding with touchdowns at the 1 yard line. And then he got cooked in the SB against an elite defense.
We're ignoring longevity?
BlueHeffner
Veteran
What’s the last memory people have of him in 2013? It wasn’t even like he went out shooting like Brady and Mahomes when they threw 50.
I was the only one on this site who said he was going to be special coming out of college. I just wish my Boys were in a position to draft him.
murksiderock
Superstar
He's not consensus Top 4 yet but it feels inevitable, he just needs the longevity..
He's not with Brady or Montana yet. You could argue him anywhere within the group of:
Manning, Brees, Marino, Favre, Rodgers, Elway, Unitas, Young...
Meaning he could be argued as high as #3. Or as low as #11...
I think he's locked in as a Top 10 GOAT, though...
BlueHeffner
Veteran
He has surpassed Dan. He's basically Dan Marino with rings. If Dan had SB rings he'd be undisputed GOAT
He's already better than Peyton. Manning spent years not playing his best in big moments. His first SB win was against a trash QB and the second he was a shell of himself getting carried by his defense.
Patrick is a better athlete and his ability to make plays under duress in the pocket and outside as well as running puts him ahead of any statue in the pocket QB's.
Brady and Montana may be more accomplished but he's the best I've seen.
rbksNgirbauds
Even on the court we stay flyy, Jada & A.I.
.Give me the gawd over Megamind every day ending in -y
rbksNgirbauds
Even on the court we stay flyy, Jada & A.I.
Need to see him without that recieving core. Cant keep em all unless Burrow giving the hometown discount
Not sure where I rank him on an all-time list in terms of career right now, but there is no reason he can't end up at the greatest.
If we're using the eye test only, it's tough to put multiple players ahead of him.
If we're using the eye test only, it's tough to put multiple players ahead of him.