Mahomes is top-4 all time

[Avisible Man]

Mahomes can have all the regular season records, which Tom currently holds. shyt, he's even got a better playoff Passer Rating. But he started in a different era with the benefit of always having Kelce and, until this year, Hill. Tom didn't get that level of weaponry till 2007 with a 30 year old Randy Moss and 2010 with Gronk, who is the most dominant TE ever, despite the injury history. Despite those advantages, he lost to Tom in the AFC Championship and the Super Bowl.

Mahomes now has a 79.7 Passer Rating in his 3 Super Bowls with 5 TD and 4 Picks . Tom, in his 10 Super Bowls, has a 97.7 Passer Rating with 21 TD to 6 Picks.

If u wanna just stick to their first 3 Super Bowls, Tom has a 99.9 Passer Rating with 6 TD to 1 Pick. His ratings went up in each SB: 86.2, 100.5, 110.2.

We can't forget that Tom started 10-0 in the playoffs. Pat lost his second game to...Tom Brady. His next playoff defeat? To...Tom Brady. That's what makes Tom the Greatest to ever do it.

 

[daboywonder2002]

Only Brady, the Sheriff, and Montana were better



2 Rings
2 SB MVPs
2 regular season MVPs

Agreeed. I think he's passed Peyton Manning. I got him 3rd

 

[Baka's Weird Case]

anybody saying there are three quarterbacks in NFL history were better than Mahomes is on Fentanyl

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

No it wasn’t. He was doing a lot of stat padding with touchdowns at the 1 yard line. And then he got cooked in the SB against an elite defense.

lol. He had maybe 5 1 yard td passes all year. What about the other 50?

People will say anything to hate. You take away all his 1 yard TDs and he's still the all time single season td leader.

 

[Jplaya2023]

Top 1
He is a better QB than Brady overall
winning SB involves a lot of fukkery, both him and brady were outplayed in some of the superbowls they won

How many superbowls was gawdtana out played in?

 

[feelosofer]

I would like to see the next few years of his career play out before crowning him as a GOAT BUT I can say he is the most talented QB I have ever seen play the position and he is on pace.

 

[BlueHeffner]

He's already better than Peyton. Manning spent years not playing his best in big moments. His first SB win was against a trash QB and the second he was a shell of himself getting carried by his defense.

Patrick is a better athlete and his ability to make plays under duress in the pocket and outside as well as running puts him ahead of any statue in the pocket QB's.

Brady and Montana may be more accomplished but he's the best I've seen.

This was literally the only SB he played well in and he only had 180 yards against a sus Eagles defense


Lets not act like he was breaking passing records in his 2 SB wins

 

[Jplaya2023]

Peyton wasn’t this in the Playoffs

That was the knock on him

Thats actually false. Besides when he became washed, most of his playoff stinkers came as a young QB or against Bill.

41-0 vs the jets
24-14 vs pats
20-3 vs the pats
Seattle SB
6int game vs chargers

The rest hes been pretty good to great and had bad luck ruin his chances.

 

[JLova]

He's already better than Peyton. Manning spent years not playing his best in big moments. His first SB win was against a trash QB and the second he was a shell of himself getting carried by his defense.

Patrick is a better athlete and his ability to make plays under duress in the pocket and outside as well as running puts him ahead of any statue in the pocket QB's.

Brady and Montana may be more accomplished but he's the best I've seen.

No. Maybe physical ability but Peyton was a computer. As great as Pat is, he still had Andy Reid as his HC.

 

[Ribbs]

I’d argue we don’t need Patrick to stay around for 20 years like Brady to give him the title of the best ever. Another chip or two and I’m giving it to him.

We haven’t seen anyone play QB better. It’s that simple.

This.

Even in the Super Bowl against the Bucs, he had an incredible performance in a losing effort.

 

[Lootpack]

Sheriff?

@Lootpack

Spoiler

Peyton is the GOAT Regular Season QB and most intelligent I've seen play. 5x MVP. Everybody else playing catch-up there. Playoff performances though? That's when things get shaky for him. Patrick got him beat in that department and the man is only 27.

 

[horizon]

I would put him as high as top 5 but that number 1 spot is not changing any time soon

 

[The War Report]

Only Brady, the Sheriff, and Montana were better



2 Rings
2 SB MVPs
2 regular season MVPs

 

[Lurkio]

mahomes will clearly surpass Manning one day


But not yet dammit

 

[Bboystyle]

We haven’t seen anyone play QB better. It’s that simple.

Yea we have