Mahomes is top-4 all time

[mastermind]

Mahomes got outplayed in 2 out of 3 SBs and arguably most AFC championships

Mahomes didn’t get outplayed tonight

 

[mastermind]

Let’s see what happens when Andy Reid isn’t his head coach

We saw Andy Reid for nearly 20 years before Mahomes became the starter.

 

[Thegospel]

Only Brady, the Sheriff, and Montana were better



2 Rings
2 SB MVPs
2 regular season MVPs

That Joe Burrow talk got shut down quick by the kid

 

[Devil Plisken…CMS]

Peyton wasn’t this in the Playoffs

That was the knock on him

 

[Thegospel]

Mahomes got outplayed in 2 out of 3 SBs and arguably most AFC championships

Put mahomes on philly and hurts in KC and this game is 50-14.

 

[Crude]

He already top 3

This

 

[The Villain]

It's only Brady and Montana above him now if he retired right today.

 

[HabitualChiller]

The problem is Mahomes got spanked in the lone Super Bowl he had against Brady

nikkas will always hang that over his head. The convo is fruitless until nikkas let another 5-7 years of Mahomes career play out

If Mahomes is in year 12, and has 4 regular season MVPs and 5 titles then we can talk about him being the GOAT. Greatest talent I’ve seen at QB? Almost certainly him & Rodgers

But talent alone doesn’t make a qb the best to ever do it

Spanked? He looked like 2018 or 2014 LeBron to me: Obviously the most talented / best player on the court / field, but the supporting cast wasn't up to par.

 

[Ain't That Something]

I wanted to say this, but i respect da gawd Peyton too much

I love Peyton, But him being carried on that last superbowl was scust. That dude got a second superbowl by default

 

[duncanthetall]

That Joe Burrow talk got shut down quick by the kid

I’m obviously a Joey Brr stan, but he’s not on Mahomes level and honestly doesn’t have the arm strength to really get there. But being #2 in the league could be enough to get a ring at some point.

Regardless, anyone trying to put Burrow or Allen over him was, is, and always will be a dummy

 

[Red Money]

He’s the best I’ve ever seen play the position. Clearly #1 based on talent.

He‘s going to need longevity and a lot of luck to surpass Brady’s resume

Aaron Rodgers in the WWE belt/discount double check era was a baller and just as talented.


Steve Young was pretty damn talented too. He accelerated Montana leaving 49ers.

 

[RickyDiBiase]

He needs 4-5 rings lets not get carried away

 

[BlueHeffner]

I love Peyton, But him being carried on that last superbowl was scust. That dude got a second superbowl by default

He was more dominant than anybody in the regular season tho

His 2013 was the magnus opus of Quarterbacking

 

[Crude]

I said a few years ago he’s going to own all those passing and TD records by the time he retires barring any serious injuries.

He’ll have at least 4-5 rings or more too which will put him in the GOAT conversation.

 

[BlueHeffner]

He needs 4-5 rings lets not get carried away

4-5 rings???

He passed Rodgers, Young, L-Way, Brees, Staubach, Favre, Marino already

Only Montana and Brady are clearly above him