I would take a passionate crowd over those random flyover state shows where the fan barley react to anything. I get what meltzer is saying but at the same time it's just fans reacting to a cool moment on the show let them live.
This is a large part of what Meltzer, Brian Zane and the other people criticizing Naomi and Bray getting the chant are missing. The crowd was really into the show, my guess is it's partly because Smackdown hasn't been to the LA area since it became clear that the show is better than RAM.
I was there in Anaheim and the chants were infectious; I didn't go with the intent of chanting that Bray or Naomi deserved it but when you're there with a couple thousand other wrestling fans who are shouting their appreciation you're compelled to shout your appreciation as well.
The chants began before Bray even got to the ring, and he took his time getting there so they were chanting for a while. And it didn't come off on TV but when he finally got to the center of the ring he bowed his head, almost like he was taking it all in and was grateful that all the jobs he's had to do finally paid off.
As far as Naomi, I didn't think she'd get the chants as there was a smattering of boos when her picture was shown for the upcoming segment, but she appreciated the chants as well. It's funny how miffed Meltzer, Alvarez, Zane, the WC cacs, and whoever else got about Naomi being told she deserves it when Rusev and other wrestlers expressed exactly that sentiment to her on Twitter.
I think Meltzer, Alvarez and some of the other people who follow wrestling full-time as a job get so damn jaded from watching hours upon hours of it that they become hyper-critical of anything that doesn't jibe with their sensibilities. The fans paid to be there, as long as they're not being vulgar or shytting on someone unnecessarily they can chant what the fukk they want to.
I notice that none of the aforementioned wrasslin 'analysts' had this much vitriol about Phoenix chanting 'lets go Ziggler' when he was beating the shyt out of Crews.