MONSTER: The Ed Gein Story | Official Teaser | Netflix

EA

A Pound & A Prayer
Joined
Jun 22, 2013
Messages
11,282
Reputation
2,880
Daps
42,385
Reppin
London, UK
I thought it was slowly turning into another season of American Horror Story, but It ends up making sense towards the last few episodes. When he’s medicated the “Ryan Murphy-isms” are reduced. I think they just used all the extra fantastical shyt to try to portray his schizophrenia.

A constant theme from all the seasons is how childhood abuse and repression can contribute to creating these “monsters”. I think that was why they put so much energy into Richard Speck and his titties lmaooo.

It’s definitely packed with speculation, shyt that came from peer interviews, or shyt he said both unmedicated and medicated. I enjoyed it overall, I just didnt take it super seriously. After the first season I realized they’re trying to visualize the “legend” of these people. The only reality they try to stick to is that they are often impulsive, idiotic human beings. The facts would only make up about 2-3 episodes lol.

My issue with the emphasis on the exploration of childhood abuse/repression is that they’ve tried to put a somewhat empathetic light on the subjects of all three seasons. I think it feels most egregious this season because Ed Gein’s backstory has the least documented evidence so it comes across like a lot of projection and speculation.

I wouldn’t have minded a shorter season if they made it a well written deep dive into his schizophrenia and how/why it led him to make him a monster (without making him appear sympathetic). Maybe they need to pick serial killers with a lot of documented evidence and interviews so they can take creative license on fact rather than making stuff up for the sake of filling out 8 episodes. I read that a major character in this didn’t even exist IRL and that’s just unnecessary.
 

987654321

Superstar
Joined
Jun 15, 2018
Messages
9,867
Reputation
5,140
Daps
35,235
My issue with the emphasis on the exploration of childhood abuse/repression is that they’ve tried to put a somewhat empathetic light on the subjects of all three seasons. I think it feels most egregious this season because Ed Gein’s backstory has the least documented evidence so it comes across like a lot of projection and speculation.

I wouldn’t have minded a shorter season if they made it a well written deep dive into his schizophrenia and how/why it led him to make him a monster (without making him appear sympathetic). Maybe they need to pick serial killers with a lot of documented evidence and interviews so they can take creative license on fact rather than making stuff up for the sake of filling out 8 episodes. I read that a major character in this didn’t even exist IRL and that’s just unnecessary.

I don’t take it as an empathetic pov. I see it as painting these “monsters” as the fukked up humans that they are. This series doesn’t seek to absolve the killers, it shows the ugliness of what they did. One thing I do like about season 1 and 3 is that they always try to include the killers acknowledging and accepting responsibility for their actions.

Too often I see people calling saying actions are evil, or calling the perpetrator a monster. I get it, but people overlook little signs and shyt every day because they have some kind of mental image of Hannibal lecter or Michael Myers when they think of killers lol.

Everytime I hear, “I never thought he would have done something like that…”, I think to myself that it’s because they weren’t looking for a human.

These serial killers are often the culmination of neglect, psychological/physical/sexual abuse, repression, on top of congenital or acquired fukked up brain chemistry. They’re often more Steve urkel than Michael Myers. I think it would be stupid to not show the human side. Maybe more people would be more willing to keep an eye on these weirdo’s, note children being abused when they see it, or get their children psychological help when they see signs of something fukked up in them.
 

Conz

Superstar
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
9,054
Reputation
810
Daps
19,539
Ryan Murphy is, i think, 0-9 with me or some shyt. i always find the ideas for his shyt interesting, watch 3 episodes at most and remember, "oh yeah, this is just gonna be a bunch of stupid gay shyt made by an absolute freak nutjob." the Hitchcock/Perkins subplot is terrible.
 

morris

Superstar
Joined
Oct 8, 2014
Messages
17,227
Reputation
5,408
Daps
37,865
And of course they had to include the pink shyt of M2M stuff... Even though this is about Gein (they highlighted Nazis over the shrunken heads from South Pacific).

I see I'm not the only one who doesn't like this

 
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
11,145
Reputation
4,155
Daps
58,624
Reppin
NULL
Well, thanks to this show I learned what a gynephiliac is, which I what suspect a good amount of transwomen actually are. As for the show, it's genuinely creepy and the cinematography is great, but damn it's like 60% lies, and it definitely felt like the director was stretching for material. It's also way too dark to be anything more than a one and done kind of show. 6/10.
 

Mister Terrific

It’s in the name
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
8,759
Reputation
2,233
Daps
28,266
Reppin
Michigan
Adeline-Watkins-alleged-girlfriend-of-convicted-murderer-Ed-Gein.jpg




:mjlol:
 

Mr Clean

Superstar
Joined
Mar 1, 2015
Messages
4,524
Reputation
2,061
Daps
27,884
As someone who watched AHS for way more years than I should have, Ryan Murphy is not to be trusted. No one else has the ability to keeping getting a good premise and do way too fukking much. Every time you think, maybe he'll actually nail it this time. Oh wait, I forgot who I was dealing with :francis:

And stop stealing roles meant for ugly people, god damn. Life is hard enough for them already
 
Top