It's all time, but the point I was making is that the Giants aren't some prestigious franchise if you take into account the last 10 years.
NFL All-Time Power Rankings, by conference
- Thread starter murksiderock
- Start date
It's all time, but the point I was making is that the Giants aren't some prestigious franchise if you take into account the last 10 years.
Every team had bad decades
For example the Patriots were a dumpster fire for 95% of the 40 years before a certain cheater coach and cheater QB came around but you're focused on the Giants?
Every team had bad decades
For example the Patriots were a dumpster fire for 95% of the 40 years before a certain cheater coach and cheater QB came around but you're focused on the Giants?
I don't care about the rankings. I was simply replying to someone who mentioned the Giants
I don't care about the rankings. I was simply replying to someone who mentioned the Giants
I'm a disgruntled Giants fan, that loss Saturday hurt
But it’s an all time ranking of franchises.The Giants have one of the worst records in the league over the last 10 years. If you're going to put the Giants so high for that logic, then the Bucs should be higher than where they are too since they have 2 Super Bowls.
Most Total NFL Wins Last 10 Years | StatMuse
Between January 29, 2016 and January 29, 2026, the Kansas City Chiefs have the most wins by a team, with 118 wins.www.statmuse.com
The Bucs have 2 SBs in franchise history. Both in the 2000s.
The Giants also have 2 SBs in the 2000s
Plus 1 in the 90s
Plus 1 in the 80s
Plus 4 NFL championships prior to that
The last 10 years argument is silly in an all time list and it’s especially silly if you bring the Bucs into the argument. Bucs have had 3 winning seasons in the past 10 years vs the Giants 2 and they should be ranked ahead? In what universe
Don’t let him off the hook. He made a dumb ass comment. Giants are easily top 4 franchise in the NFC all time. Talking about the past 10 years when TB’s only winning season in the 80s was 1981 and didn’t have another winning season until 1997. YikesI'm a disgruntled Giants fan, that loss Saturday hurt
But it’s an all time ranking of franchises.
The Bucs have 2 SBs in franchise history. Both in the 2000s.
The Giants also have 2 SBs in the 2000s
Plus 1 in the 90s
Plus 1 in the 80s
Plus 4 NFL championships prior to that
The last 10 years argument is silly in an all time list and it’s especially silly if you bring the Bucs into the argument. Bucs have had 3 winning seasons in the past 10 years vs the Giants 2 and they should be ranked ahead? In what universe
Again... my comment was on the "4 Super Bowls in the modern era" comment. My point is the Giants are not an elite franchise in the "modern era." If you want to point to the 4 Super Bowl titles, then all I am saying is the Bucs should be higher than where they are with their 2 Super Bowl titles with the same logic. I don't understand why that's so hard to understand
And again, I don't agree with any of the OP rankings & don't care to rank them myself.
Giants been to 5 super bowls and won 4 in the modern era.Giants are too high but yall not ready for that conversation
And in general the past is given too much weight, I understand these are all-time rankings but if the peak of your franchise was before there was true parity and competition you should lose some points but we not ready for that convo either
Who you puttin ahead of them.So basically someone saying the Giants are too high on the ALL time list and my response using 8 NFL chips, 4 in the modern era led you to quote me with an argument for the Bucs to be ranked higher? Makes no sense to say the Giants are not elite in the Modern era.Again... my comment was on the "4 Super Bowls in the modern era" comment. My point is the Giants are not an elite franchise in the "modern era." If you want to point to the 4 Super Bowl titles, then all I am saying is the Bucs should be higher than where they are with their 2 Super Bowl titles with the same logic. I don't understand why that's so hard to understand
And again, I don't agree with any of the OP rankings & don't care to rank them myself.
Only the Cowboys and 9ers have more championships in the NFC all time and GB has 4 just like us.
NYG last SB - 2011
GB last SB - 2010
Dallas last SB - 1995
9ers last SB - 1994
So I’ll ask again:
Who should rank higher than NYG?
Where should the Bucs rank?
Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
Bengals should be higher than the other WOATs... they've been to three Super Bowls.
murksiderock
Superstar
They are on the way up but there's no way they get over Cleveland yet, that's three (AFC) spots ahead. The Chargers and Titans are directly ahead of them, they'll likely bump one of em imminently. But they were garbage for more than half of their history, and don't have a single title to show for the good years. There's levels here, and they are certainly escalating, but it's only so high they can go with what they've put on the board to date...
Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
i just view it this way... Titans and Chargers have only been to 1 Super Bowl and never won. They may be better regular season teams but the name of the game is to advance as far as you can.. Bengals have been to the Super Bowl 3 times so they have 3 AFC championships and they never got blown out in the Super Bowl either.
Is this what nikkas do when their team ain’t shyt anymore.
Giants went to the Super Bowl:
1986
1990
2000
2007
2011
They won 4 outta 5 What other NFC teams are better than that?
The raiders are iconic sports franchise. It’s crazy what has happened the last 20 years