NFR & The Needle Drop Rank The 10 Best Discographies In Hip Hop

[Diondon]

FOH cac

 

[DontEemTry]

Of course this turned into a Nas vs Jay thread. I wonder why

 

[Mr 18]

Of course this turned into a Nas vs Jay thread. I wonder why

Fighting for a spot at the bottom of the list

 

[Illmagic]

By who?

I'm a Nas stan, and I only liked Magic.

Most of this site and people online think Hit-Boy is trash too. So I'm just speaking objectively. Nas was already GOATed before those projects. They didn't do anything for his legacy. This album coming with Primo will though.

All of them were dope except Magic 2. KD3 and Magic were phenomenal. Nas lapped a lot of rappers careers in 3 years. And he did it at 50. When you really think about it Nas’s catalog is untouchable. He’s absolutely number 1. Kanye and Jay are probably 2 and 3.

 

[King Harlem]

A lot of y'all are killing these guys lists, without providing your own. It's always easy to criticize lists when you don't have to make one.

 

[Overpss]

All of them were dope except Magic 2. KD3 and Magic were phenomenal. Nas lapped a lot of rappers careers in 3 years. And he did it at 50. When you really think about it Nas’s catalog is untouchable. He’s absolutely number 1. Kanye and Jay are probably 2 and 3.

They're not even top 5 discography wise lol. The lists in op are actually pretty accurate and represent the consensus for legitimate reasons.

 

[Ike omad]

A lot of y'all are killing these guys lists, without providing your own. It's always easy to criticize lists when you don't have to make one.

Their lists are really good actually, they played it safe by having the regular top 10 that everyone comes up with, but at least they didn't try to go against the grain just for the sake of getting views.

 

[Hum Alistair]

At this point the top 3 is cemented and written in stone, and whats crazy is this has been the exact same top 3 for years: Kanye, Kendrick, Outkast

 

[King Harlem]

Their lists are really good actually, they played it safe by having the regular top 10 that everyone comes up with, but at least they didn't try to go against the grain just for the sake of getting views.

I thought so too. I'm trying to point out that if others do a list and include: Scarface, Mobb Deep, Common, etc. then you will have to leave someone out. It's a harder task then it seems. Also, this has turned into 'who cares what they think, they are White'.

 

[mundL]

Nas
Ghostface
Black Thought

objectively thats the top 3 imo

 

[semicko82]

No Future

 

[Illmagic]

They're not even top 5 discography wise lol. The lists in op are actually pretty accurate and represent the consensus for legitimate reasons.

Nas Jay and Kanye are not top 5 discography wise? People have seriously lost their minds

 

[Mike Wins]

The Kenny stan with 18 accounts is furious at the turn this thread took

 

[King Harlem]

At this point the top 3 is cemented and written in stone, and whats crazy is this has been the exact same top 3 for years: Kanye, Kendrick, Outkast

Does one or two more bad Kanye albums push him out of the top 3? Or are those classic albums so good it will keep him safe?

 

[Awesome Wells]

Their lists are really good actually, they played it safe by having the regular top 10 that everyone comes up with, but at least they didn't try to go against the grain just for the sake of getting views.

True.

The lists aren't that bad. But you gotta have Cube, PE, Scarface, De La and a couple others that were missing. Their lists look like they just started listening to Hip Hop in 1999-00. That's usually when the casuals popped up, but then think they're Hip Hip historians, lol.