Larry Lambo
Superstar
The OP is all over the place...
On one hand you're saying nice guy tactics don't "work" and the nice guys are told it's their fault....
But nice guy tactics do work....just often not on the women the nice guys are going after. Most devout Christian woman and other sheltered types....see what we are calling "nice guy" here as the norm.
It's like being a housecat but expecting to catch and pull down an antelope. That's for lions. Stick to mice.
Ehh, some truth to that, but there's more to it.
The reality is a lot of "regular" chicks (including the sheltered Christian women you refer to) are being sold dreams to dudes above their level and many of them are gonna pick that guy every time over the guy with the intention to commit for real. Most of us have sold dreams a couple times ourselves, so we know what we're dealing with. He'll take her on a few dates, wine and dine her, and then 3 months into it, he gets tired of the P and moves on.
It's not about finding a regular chick, it's about finding a regular chick that tired of the games and is realistic about the type of men that would really be interested in a long term relationship.
It's also about gaining her trust and bonding with her to the point, where she can turn down a more appealing but "shakier" offer from a dude out of her league. This is why I believe it's better to look for wifey type chicks in your social circle/work/organization so that you can build that relationship with her before dating vs. trying to win her over on dates when she has all kinds of dudes trying to do the same. It's difficult to connect with a woman on par with you, on the random, unless your mouthpiece is impeccable. There's too much to deal with to stick out.
no longer single. Have a good night.

Dude stop talking you have lost all credibility. We have nothing left in discuss.