Devil Plisken…CMS
Veteran
In terms of just flat out skill and just rapping I think they're even, there's been different versions of Jay over the years but there's only really been one Cole though and I think that's the main thing that sets them apart. Jay's reinvented himself a few times and while it hasn't always worked it's given him a lot of variance in content so I'll take him over Cole in that regard. Cole's never dropped a bad album IMO (4YEO is probably the closest but still not a bad album) but I think Jay has dropped a few.
All in all, I think just the longevity of Jay and him being able to exist in different eras of rap gives him the nod and the advantage, but I think Cole is just as good of a rapper bar for bar, he just doesn't have the diversity Jay has had.
lol



