Prime for Prime Carmelo or Dwight?

[CHICAGO]

They gutted the team to get him...never put a good team around him

My point is put those Nuggets in the East & he gets out. This isn't debatable

THIS IS FANTASY TALK...

PUT BRON ON THOSE NUGGETS TEAMS IN THE WEST
AND HE WINS THE WEST...

PUT MELO ON THOSE CAVS TEAMS
AND HE STILL DOESNT GET OUT THE 1ST ROUND.

THOSE NUGGETS TEAMS WERE STACKED
AND SHOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER
BUT MELOS STYLE OF PLAY
ISNT WINNING BASKETBALL.



​

 

[The God Poster]

THIS IS FANTASY TALK...

PUT BRON ON THOSE NUGGETS TEAMS IN THE WEST
AND HE WINS THE WEST...

PUT MELO ON THOSE CAVS TEAMS
AND HE STILL DOESNT GET OUT THE 1ST ROUND.



​

Bron is leaps & bounds a much better player....

 

[staticshock]

Bill Russell
Moses Malone
Alonzo Mourning
David Robinson

All better at that point still....I get he from ATL but chill out

I disagree fam but not mad at your list..

no C is touching prime Shaq tho. thats my goat

 

[Sccit]

Shaq
Abdul-Jabar
Chamberlain
Hakeem
Dwight

Did you see prime Dwight you cac fakkit?

OF COURSE I HAVE, TRANNY CHASER .. UNLIKE U, IM NOT 12 YEARS OLD.

THE MVP OF THOSE MAGIC TEAMS WAS THE SYSTEM .. DWIGHTS ENTIRE OFFENSE WAS PREDICATED ON SPOONFED DUNKS AND PUTBACKS. SVG RAN AN OFFENSE WITH 4 KNOCK DOWN SHOOTERS TO SPREAD THE COURT, LEAVING DWIGHT ALONE IN THE MIDDLE TO DO THE DIRTY WORK. HE WAS DAMN NEAR INTERCHANGEABLE WIT TYSON CHANDLER.

I KNEW U WERE AN IDIOT, BUT CALLIN DWIGHT A TOP 5 CENTER TAKES THE CAKE.

ROBINSON
EWING
RUSSELL
WALTON
MOSES
MOURNING
PARISH
MUTOMBO
GILMORE

ALL LIGHTYEARS AHEAD OF DWIGHT

KILL YASELF

 

[NoHalfWay]

I disagree fam but not mad at your list..

no C is touching prime Shaq tho. thats my goat

I don’t think you disagreeing will change the fact that Dwight Howard does not rank higher than a 12x all-star, 3x MVP, and Finals MVP in Moses Malone breh

 

[CHICAGO]

Bron is leaps & bounds a much better player....

YOURE THE ONE WHO KEEPS
MENTIONING BRON THOUGH.




​

 

[Supreme365]

Carmelo is a Top 10 offensive talent of all time, so this is an unfair comparison

You can’t be serious

Mj
Kobe
Bron
Cap
Kd
Tmac
Bird
Iverson
Wilt
Malone
Barkley
Drob
Duncan
Dirk
Curry
Magic
Nash
Gervin
Mcadoo
Pierce
Wade
Shaq
Kyrie
Westbrook

And that’s just off the top of my head

 

[Monsanto]

Melo.

Dwight had a team built around him.

That very same team had Nelson, Reddikk, Hedo and Lewis not missing during the offs.

Those dudes caught lightning in the bottle similar to the Mavs during their title run.

Melo and the Nuggets lost that series against the Lakers because of Karl Malone.

Anthony Carter inbound.


That was Melo's year. Aside from them both peaking playoffs wins that year Melo had more sustained success.

 

[Monsanto]

You can’t be serious

Mj
Kobe
Bron
Cap
Kd
Tmac
Bird
Iverson
Wilt
Malone
Barkley
Drob
Duncan
Dirk
Curry
Magic
Nash
Gervin
Mcadoo
Pierce
Wade
Shaq
Kyrie
Westbrook

And that’s just off the top of my head

This list is horrible.

 

[Supreme365]

This list is horrible.

All of those guys have a greater offensive impact then Melo please tell which ones don’t so I can expose the casual in you

 

[UpAndComing]

You can’t be serious

Mj
Kobe
Bron
Cap
Kd
Tmac
Bird
Iverson
Wilt
Malone
Barkley
Drob
Duncan
Dirk
Curry
Magic
Nash
Gervin
Mcadoo
Pierce
Wade
Shaq
Kyrie
Westbrook

And that’s just off the top of my head

I said offensive TALENT, not offensive output. The natural god given ability to score with ease. You're just naming names at this point


Only the bolded I would easily put over Melo

The others are straight up laughable

 

[Cadillac]

Im goin dwight

 

[Supreme365]

I said offensive TALENT, not offensive output. The natural god given ability to score with ease. You're just naming names at this point


Only the bolded I would easily put over Melo

The others are straight up laughable

Please explain how Kobe and bron aren’t better offensively than Melo
You’ll overrate Melo he has a lot of pretty moves but it never carries over to the playoffs
He has never been as dominant offensively as anyone I named and just so you know passing is apart of offense
You’ll don’t know hoops

 

[Chris Cool]

MELO ONLY GOT OUT THE 1ST ROUND 1 TIME...

THATS NOT TRANSLATING TO FINALS
AND MULTIPLE CONFERENCE FINALS APPEARANCES.

HE WOULDNT HAVE BEATEN THE PISTONS,
SHAQ HEAT, CELTICS NOR BRON.



​

He got to wcf as a nugget and 2nd round as a knick.

 

[Chris Cool]

Dwight made it to the finals... In the east. Idk why some are acting like that's a big deal, melo's nuggets would've smashed them easily if not for the Lakers.


His 2nd round knicks probably could've done more if 6th man of the year jr Smith doesn't get suspended and completely falls off.