1.How do you rectify advocating for patriarchy ITT yet promoting Black womanism in other threads? It doesn't add up.
2. Do Black folks live in a patriarchal community? Thats a very dubious claim. Is the solution as easy as Black men waking up one day and becoming capitalist as if economic apartheid isn't real?
What I do know is that in terms of child rearing and the household, Black women should have outsized influence, a role, and say in how we fix problems that arise.
3 It is literally anti-woman to suggest that men should lead them on matters pertaining to the children they bring into the world and are attached to in ways men will never be....thats the literal essence of maternity.
4. If anything, showing "whataboutism" helps people NOT fall into the trap of thinking its one gender inflicting all the ills in the community and that its more so a generational poverty issue...there isn't something inherently evil with either gender, we are both inflicting trauma because of our environment/history.
5. Why does humanizing Black boys/men upset some of you so much? Literally not humanizing Black men leads to stuff like radical Black feminism where our women are fed propaganda about Black men being some unique arbiter of evil because they only get fed one side.
1. Pointing out that Patriarchy exists and where our abilities lie in it is not advocating it. Its not different than telling Cacs that white supremacy exists and that they hold more power to end it/use it for good or evil than Black people.
2. Patriarchy, just like white privilege isn't the ability for men/cacs to suddenly be rich and powerful. Its the state of existence in that power, wealth, and influence are more
easily attainable for men/cacs than for women/black folk. Its also the state of existence where power is considered "greater" when a man/cac wields it than a woman/black folk.
Yes, Black women in the black community are often time the head of family due to the absence of men (for various reason). But they are simply
DE FACTO leaders. Leaders who are merely acting in absence because someone
has to. In a matriarchy, women would be
given this power/authority by men who hold a present and contributing role in that society.
Their is no cure-all solution. But IMO the
closest way we can get there (outside of toppling white supremacy/ global capitalism) is by participating as best we can in the job market, in particular STEM fields. We presently are not doing that, mostly in part to the cycle of Black poverty which has created the dissolution of the Black family and no core values/goals to adhere to. Racism is a vast barrier , but in the Information Age and with the revitalization of cities that is occurring across the nation, Blacks are in the
best chance we've ever had to get a little more further from the poverty cycle.
3. See points 1 and 2
4. Id say it depends on the context of why we're having the conversation. In a vacuum speaking about sexual abuse in the black community and how Black Boys are just as abused as Black Girls is a valid topic. Immediately starting out the conversation by saying "Black mothers are awarded custody and put boys in toxic environments...." is kind of a indicator that you're creating a "ITS fukkING BLACK WOMENS FAULT" narrative. Thats petty, doesn't tell the whole story, and only seeks to play into the gender wars. For the record, Id say the exact same thing if it were implied that its all black mens fault.
5. Nothing wrong with pointing out that Black men suffer. What i have a problem with is deflecting any sort of criticism, using whatboutism to change the subject, and then claiming someone is trying to stop Black progress when they tell you that youre fukking up. Its part of the problem.