RDR or GTA4?

[BonafideDefacto]

They ironed out most of the issues like adding checkpoints in missions etc., put in loads of new shyt, radio stations have double the music and shyt.

Then the stories are epic. The protaagonists are probably better than Niko as well.

I never bought red dead but i did play it at my homies crib. I think i still might buy gta1v add-ons before RD.

 

[Wiirdo]

I never bought red dead but i did play it at my homies crib. I think i still might buy gta1v add-ons before RD.

Finish the episodes cos they are

Then move on to Red Dead which is

 

[puppetmaster]

Never finished Red Dead, this thread has me feeling like mistakes were made






-P-

 

[havoc00]

Never finished Red Dead, this thread has me feeling like mistakes were made






-P-

 

[Broke Wave]

red dead is among the goat ever games

 

[Heretic]

If you haven't copped Undead Nightmare I suggest you go and do so

RDR > GTA IV
TBoGT > Undead though

Whatever u do op cop the goty edition but dont play undead nightmare until you beat rdr

 

[Tom]

Red Dead

but Ballad of Gay Tony should have just been GTAIV and they shoulda threw Niko in the Bushes

 

[Tom]

yo, I'm playing Undead Nightmare now, I saved all the towns and burnt all the coffins and now there is absolutely nothing left to do but ride around on my demonic fire horse and go sight seeing


Am I doing something wrong?

 

[The G.O.D II]

I want a sequel but it must be done right. And I dont know if it can since the old west is pretty limited in terms of gameplay/story. Maybe they can have a premise on the struggle between the old west and modern times? Maybe a story of how folks from the east coast came out and started building casinos and other modern entities?

Spoiler

Plus the son was gay as fukk. I dont know if I would want to play as him

 

[Tom]

if they do a sequel is will most likely be a prequel

 

[The G.O.D II]

if they do a sequel is will most likely be a prequel

Naw the prequel was already the original RDR on the PS2. They need some shyt set in the 30/40's with cowboys like Marston taking on the encroachment of Mob figures and other carpetbagging characters.

 

[Black Magisterialness]

RDR of course...bestt game of this generation.....

RDR
Skyrim
Uncharted 2
are hands down to me the best games of the gen...

 

[The G.O.D II]

yo, I'm playing Undead Nightmare now, I saved all the towns and burnt all the coffins and now there is absolutely nothing left to do but ride around on my demonic fire horse and go sight seeing


Am I doing something wrong?

Sometimes missions just pop up. You gotta ride around Have you made it to Mexico yet? I'm on the part where I have to do shyt for that crazy ass snake oil salesmen doctor before I met him there

 

[Tom]

Sometimes missions just pop up. You gotta ride around Have you made it to Mexico yet? I'm on the part where I have to do shyt for that crazy ass snake oil salesmen doctor before I met him there

I'm talking about Undead nightmare bro, not RDR

 

[The G.O.D II]

I'm talking about Undead nightmare bro, not RDR

I know. Thats where I'm at in UDN