Who has ever tried to push the notion that Russ was the main reason that Seattlr.won?? The star of that show in real time, was always the defense, then Beast Mode, then Russ. Luck played in a different offense, in a dome, in a weaker offense. If he played for Carroll, with Marshawn and that defense, his attempts are going down. If he produced the exact same results as Russ did, with the same team, no one would question it. You mentioned Luck and Manning, I am not arguing that Russ is their equivalent, In saying he was a good to very good QB even from 2012-2014. That is in real time and with the benefit of hindsight.