Saban vs Belicheck...who’s the overall goat?

[#1 pick]

Saban. It's not even close

The NFL is a QB league, if he was doing this with Trent Dilfer, I'll be amazed but Tom Brady is GOAT. So not as much.

 

[CrimsonTider]

Saban

SEC > AFC EAST

 

[RubioTheCruel]

I like Saban as a coach but it has to be said that in any given season there's only 1 or 2 games per year where he doesn't have a stark advantage in overall roster talent. I don't think it's a real apples to apples comparison

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

Although there are obvious similarities, it really requires two different skillsets to excel at each level. For instance, I don't believe Beli's "Do your job" philosophy would work as well with such drastically varying degrees of talent on the roster (future pro talent lined up next to future accountants). And we saw how Saban performed dealing with a roster full of pro level talent playing against pro level talent each week.

 

[Monoblock]

Beli and it aint close.

 

[Copy Ninja]

College is won and lost in the recruiting trail. In the NFL, it's all about X's and O's.

Saban is the GOAT recruiter. I'll take BB coaching the team.

 

[brownsugah]

Popovich or Coach K

The realest answer in this thread.

 

[Box Factory]

Saban was a joke in the NFL

 

[No1]

Sure the NFL is the highest level, but I mean it's all relative though.

Saban has to do it with practically brand new teams every 3 years. Bill has had continuity at the most important position, QB, for his entire tenure for the most part.

Nevermind the fact that you have to win EVERY week essentially in college. Nevermind the fact that the Patriots are constantly caught cheating and given handouts by the league.

I'm going with Saban, fukk how you feel.

What a stupid post.

 

[Loose]

College is won and lost in the recruiting trail. In the NFL, it's all about X's and O's.

Saban is the GOAT recruiter. I'll take BB coaching the team.

Georgia and Texas has dominated recruiting trails the last 15 years..

 

[Jplaya2023]

pro's >> amateurs

 

[YaThreadTrashB!]

Sure the NFL is the highest level, but I mean it's all relative though.

Saban has to do it with practically brand new teams every 3 years. Bill has had continuity at the most important position, QB, for his entire tenure for the most part.

Nevermind the fact that you have to win EVERY week essentially in college. Nevermind the fact that the Patriots are constantly caught cheating and given handouts by the league.

I'm going with Saban, fukk how you feel.

The average nfl career is 3 years, nfl teams have crazy turnover year in and year out

 

[Dame Dash's Motor Oil]

fukk Nick Saban and anybody that love him

 

[Illeye buckmatic]

I'd like to see Saban in a second NFL stint.

But Belichick is better right now.

Some say Jimmy Johnson should be up there since he won in both college and the NFL.

Should Barry Switzer?

 

[Illeye buckmatic]