Saban vs Belicheck...who’s the overall goat?

[FabTrey]

beli easily.

nfl chip = / = college chip

talent level is evenly distributed in the nfl. bama got too much talent.

 

[kevm3]

Belichick. Alabama is stacked with the best recruits year in and year out. The Patriots are drafting near the end of every round every year.

 

[Amare's Right Hook]

Saban was an average coach in NFL. Belichick is maybe the greatest strategist I've seen in any sport.

*pulls play out of sock

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Saban has to do it with practically brand new teams every 3 years.

More than half the schedule is games that I could coach and they'd still win. The talent gap is severe. The talent gap in the NFL is not nearly as much, not even close. Beli has to scheme for every team and every situation and adjust at all times. He can't take days off during the season. The NFL is a completely different animal

 

[BucciMane]

Saban is great in college football, but there was an article last year that came out where it was saying when Saban worked with Belichick, he could not keep up and was beyond exhausted. If. Belichick got to recruit anyone he wanted..

I'll almost always go with the pro coach as well.

 

[MrBillCollecta]

Belicheck

 

[Absolut]

Sure the NFL is the highest level, but I mean it's all relative though.

Saban has to do it with practically brand new teams every 3 years. Bill has had continuity at the most important position, QB, for his entire tenure for the most part.

Nevermind the fact that you have to win EVERY week essentially in college. Nevermind the fact that the Patriots are constantly caught cheating and given handouts by the league.

I'm going with Saban, fukk how you feel.

hes won twice without even winning his conference, but has to win every week

 

[KingJay]

Coach Pop

 

[WhoShotCha]

hes won twice without even winning his conference, but has to win every week

Semantics. Everyone knows in college football you have to essentially win every week dumb ass nikka.

 

[WhoShotCha]

More than half the schedule is games that I could coach and they'd still win. The talent gap is severe. The talent gap in the NFL is not nearly as much, not even close. Beli has to scheme for every team and every situation and adjust at all times. He can't take days off during the season. The NFL is a completely different animal

Saban is the REASON the talent gap is so large between Bama and their competitors. Do you know how rigorous recruiting is? He spends hours evaluating talent and sitting in nikkas living rooms and STILL has to gameplan every week in a sport where 2 bad weeks and it's over.

 

[who_better_than_me]

New England Patriots at Miami Dolphins - December 10th, 2006 | Pro-Football-Reference.com


Only shutout ever of the Brady-Belicheck era

 

[who_better_than_me]

I wish Sabah would've stay longer. It looked like he was really starting to figure out the pro's before he left.

 

[dakidblu]

Imagine if beli could recruit all the top talent like saban could in college. My god pats would be going like 15-1 every year at worst.

 

[CrimsonTider]

Beli easily. Might be a hall of famer just off his DC resume. made 'patsies' into a dynasty.

recruiting isn't something that happens on the field, and it's heavily related to the program. Saban isn't an X and Os coach either

really, it's Beli by a landslide

You’re stupid if you don’t think Saban is an X &Os coach

 

[yseJ]

You’re stupid if you don’t think Saban is an X &Os coach

please make some argument as to how he's a good Xs and Os coach. especially even remotely compared to Beli

of course, if people consider Harbaugh good at Xs and Os, then Saban is a fukking mastermind. but you gotta have some standards.