TLR Is Mental Poison

The Coli Is Not For You
Supporter
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
46,178
Reputation
7,490
Daps
105,799
Reppin
The Opposite Of Elliott Wilson's Mohawk
Survival vs Excessive corporate profit.
"Excessive" in your questionably thought out opinion. And companies cannot survive without profit. You have socialists literally proposing for companies to operate at an unsustainable loss as the only "fair" way to treat workers. It's ridiculous.
 

BaggerofTea

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Sep 15, 2014
Messages
52,182
Reputation
-1,249
Daps
255,469
"Excessive" in your questionably thought out opinion. And companies cannot survive without profit. You have socialists literally proposing for companies to operate at an unsustainable loss as the only "fair" way to treat workers. It's ridiculous.

Whats "unsustainable loss"? Not being able to pay out 9 figures in corporate bonuses and millions upon millions in funding political superpacs?
 

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
325,243
Reputation
-34,127
Daps
632,516
Reppin
The Deep State
It doesn't matter economic theory you subscribe to, if you don't have raw materials to extract. You have no industry. No industry means no motivation for innovation.
managing that motivation is economics.

I do not think "socialism" provides enough incentive to manage that, or inspire that.
 

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
325,243
Reputation
-34,127
Daps
632,516
Reppin
The Deep State
Whats "unsustainable loss"? Not being able to pay out 9 figures in corporate bonuses and millions upon millions in funding political superpacs?
The only people making 9 figures in bonuses are people who are in charge of massive companies so its a handful

1. Superpacs need reform

2. Corporate bonuses are only few those that can afford to pay them which is dependent on the size of the company and how much money they make...so even then, even with a few million, they wouldn't increase other workers wages by that much if just spread out like that.
 

TLR Is Mental Poison

The Coli Is Not For You
Supporter
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
46,178
Reputation
7,490
Daps
105,799
Reppin
The Opposite Of Elliott Wilson's Mohawk
Whats "unsustainable loss"? Not being able to pay out 9 figures in corporate bonuses and millions upon millions in funding political superpacs?
Every company is not some multibillion dollar multinational :francis:

And unsustainable loss = going out of business. If a company spends more than it takes in, it's going to go out of business, and take all of those workers' jobs with it. So the interests of the business have to be factored into the equation.

This infantile, binary "us vs them" good guy bad guy bullshyt undermines socialist progress. If you guys just want to pontificate and masturbate to Marx then you can stay in your bubble. But if socialism is really going to take a hold in the real world the people pushing it have to have some working understanding of the world they are trying to sell socialism to. Screaming vague platitudes about "exploitation" is not going to cut the mustard with anybody intelligent
 

Aufheben

All Star
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
1,753
Reputation
1,030
Daps
10,781
Reppin
Nowhere
No its not. If Norway wasn't blessed with oil deposits, they'd be another portugal :stopitslime:

Sweden? They had to lower taxes and they STILL can't get enough domestic growth.

Finland? Another basket case.

Some of ya'll take this shyt too far.

Even in Denmark, people say the amount they pay in taxes just isn't worth the marginal benefits they get.

Not every country is Germany :ufdup:

what the fukk are you talking about? :wtf: Sweden has been doing better recovering since the recession than the US, UK and Germany. they've been exceeding all forecasts :laff:

UuNUa0Y.png


every economy has ups and downs. the facts are that on nearly every social indicator these countries are better than us and it's not going to stop any time soon no matter what uninformed shyt you continue to spew across these boards. :umad:
 

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
325,243
Reputation
-34,127
Daps
632,516
Reppin
The Deep State
what the fukk are you talking about? :wtf: Sweden has been doing better recovering since the recession than the US, UK and Germany. they've been exceeding all forecasts :laff:

UuNUa0Y.png


every economy has ups and downs. the facts are that on nearly every social indicator these countries are better than us and it's not going to stop any time soon no matter what uninformed shyt you continue to spew across these boards. :umad:


IMF Survey : Sweden’s Economy is Robust, but Faces Challenges in Housing, Labor Markets

:francis:
 

Tate

Kae☭ernick Loyalist
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Messages
4,274
Reputation
800
Daps
15,042
The most important thing is that people acknowledge that socialism is a process and communism is the end result. Its also why marxist/socialist/communists should be advocates for futurism and enhancing the means of the production to enable the the class construct to disappear bottom up.

I am an admitted state-ist, but I believe in democratic marxism. I revere Lenin for his ability to articulate his message but Leninism, Stalinism and Trotskyism were basically fronts for elites.

Once you advocate for some semblance of "chosen representation" you effectively have created an elite class.

Bit unfair to Late Trotsky here. Lev came around to supporting active democracy both within and without the party.


I'll be back with some stuff (maybe), but whether you're a statist or not... the Pan-African scientific socialism that influenced DuBois, Malcolm X and Stokely Carmichael should be stressed here.

I also posted Black Like Mao some time ago detailing Red China's influence on the 60s-70s Black Liberation movement (Panthers, Stokely, RAM, etc.), which to me is a better gateway to socialism (how I got into it personally) than Lenin and those guys.

We could also do a thread on the tired and too oft. repeated Cold War propaganda that gets tossed around here incessantly.

It wasn't my path but I do find this to be true. Maoism has some big flaws and I've never been particularly interested in it but most black communists/socialists I meet atleast get there through Mao inspired stuff and third world struggle. I've never really studied it but the Frankfurt school also is supposedly good for similar reasons in its relevance to American life relative to Marx and Lenin.


Brehs, I'm gonna need some insight into how the working class can win its freedom when such a large majority of the class is mystified by bourgeois ideas on the economy, racism, homophobia, sexism, etc. The more information becomes available, the dumber people get :leostare: How could barely literate Russians in the early 1900s come to realize that they were getting royally fukked and tried to fight to establish a different society, yet we have the world's information at our fingertips and a multitude of ways to see all the ways we're getting screwed, but still perpetuate the system?

The subtlety of wage exploitation is the difference here, The longstanding agricultural exploitation of feudalism in Russia provided a huge majority of effectively sympathetic citizens upon which a radicalized industrial proletariat, which was very centralized in two cities, could build. This is a common theme in most places socialist revolution has occurred.

You can see this in the U.S. as well even. The strongest times for the left was when there was still a large portion of small agriculture workers and quasi feudal relations to large landholders.

I'm not sure that comparison works, but I'm not trying to derail the thread or get into a pointless back and forth.

I just feel like, outside of neolithic societies, there's few examples of socialism actually working. Marx called the first European socialists utopian, and I tend to think the same of socialism in general. I think it's hard to get past the reality that there's a basic human instinct to promote self interest. Every society needs a power structure, every societal power structure is human, and is therefor subject to corruption and tyranny.

I know, I know...Sweden. To be fair, the book is still unwritten on Nordic socialism; not enough time has passed to use that example to disprove the countless times where socialism has failed.

Like all things, compromise seems to be the best bet. In that sense I agree with a lot of Social Democratic ideas. But technically Marxists view Social Democrats as collaborators with the oppressors, and, therefore, the enemy. I feel like that point gets lost on most neo-Marxists.

No its not. If Norway wasn't blessed with oil deposits, they'd be another portugal :stopitslime:

Sweden? They had to lower taxes and they STILL can't get enough domestic growth.

Finland? Another basket case.

Some of ya'll take this shyt too far.

Even in Denmark, people say the amount they pay in taxes just isn't worth the marginal benefits they get.

Not every country is Germany :ufdup:

You're so disingenuous it's ridiculous. Social democratic parties have lost voters to populist parties which basically promise social democracy, but only for natives.

There was literally a poll in Finland last year asking if Finns would support even higher taxes to maintain the welfare state, like 90% support. Scandinavians love the welfare state. They have issues with an aging population, which is solvable with increased immigration but is in part driving an uptick in nativism. It's contentious but not a real issue until any nativist party or party that actually wants to dismantle the welfare state(which no major right party in Scandinavia wants to do) actually leads a government. The welfare states are popular and not going anywhere.
 

Aufheben

All Star
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
1,753
Reputation
1,030
Daps
10,781
Reppin
Nowhere

:laff: did you just google "sweden economy problems" and copy pasted what you first saw?

first you said: "they STILL can't get enough domestic growth." and i showed you that they have more than enough growth and are in fact the fastest growing economy in the developed world. :dead:

now you bringing up housing and labor issues they face like every other economy. just quit talking about shyt you don't know :camby: it's nothing wrong with acknowledging your own ignorance :umad:
 

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
325,243
Reputation
-34,127
Daps
632,516
Reppin
The Deep State
You're so disingenuous it's ridiculous. Social democratic parties have lost voters to populist parties which basically promise social democracy, but only for natives.

There was literally a poll in Finland last year asking if Finns would support even higher taxes to maintain the welfare state, like 90% support. Scandinavians love the welfare state. They have issues with an aging population, which is solvable with increased immigration but is in part driving an uptick in nativism. It's contentious but not a real issue until any nativist party or party that actually wants to dismantle the welfare state(which no major right party in Scandinavia wants to do) actually leads a government. The welfare states are popular and not going anywhere.
I didn't say that they were unpopular. I said they're undergoing reforms and are currently facing existential crises from funding and implementation

www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/65438762-6fef-11e4-a0c4-00144feabdc0.html The End of Nordic Illusions
 

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
325,243
Reputation
-34,127
Daps
632,516
Reppin
The Deep State
:laff: did you just google "sweden economy problems" and copy pasted what you first saw?

first you said: "they STILL can't get enough domestic growth." and i showed you that they have more than enough growth and are in fact the fastest growing economy in the developed world. :dead:

now you bringing up housing and labor issues they face like every other economy. just quit talking about shyt you don't know :camby: it's nothing wrong with acknowledging your own ignorance :umad:
search my post history. i' have entire threads on this topic.

The nordic model is going t*ts up...with tons of data and insight.
 
Top