Star Wars Episode I vs Episode II: Which one is truly the WOAT?

[MartyMcFly]

Both are terrible. Hilarious and sad that Lucas felt Jar Jar was the "key" to episode I being a success. What was he thinking?

That video of them watching the first cut before release says it all. Lucas knew he fukked up. Terrible writing.

It is like asking which is better between a sandwich with 3 days worth of mold and a sandwich with two days worth of mold

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

Ep 2 was kinda dope (imo). Mace windu, Yoda, Count Dooku, Anakin's emergence, Clones, Jango Fett, Jedi council.

Ep 1 was about as boring as Ep 4 to me. Shoulda just truncated that shyt and had him be a teenager later on in this film instead. Really wish it ended with the discovery of the clone army
and have Ep 2 focus more on the clone war itself.

Jar Jar binks makes Ep 1 the worst star wars movie by default tho. He has no redeeming qualities other than being a bumbling idiot. And im pretty sure he's modern day, CGI black face.

A black actor played jar jar.

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

It is like asking which is better between a sandwich with 3 days worth of mold and a sandwich with two days worth of mold

Was Lucas high thinking jar jar was the key though? U watch that doc on episode 1? The whole thing is facinating but sad at the same time.

 

[MartyMcFly]

Was Lucas high thinking jar jar was the key though? U watch that doc on episode 1? The whole thing is facinating but sad at the same time.

Is it on the blu?

 

[-DMP-]

A black actor played jar jar.

its even worst than I imagined

 

[NobodyReally]

Episode II is the absolute worst movie of that year...maybe even the decade. Never in my life have I actually laughed during a supposedly serious moment like I did in that movie. The script and acting was so bad it almost prevented me from seeing Sith. It's that horrible.

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

Is it on the blu?

I don't have the blu. Watch it here. Good watch.

 

[Hi!]

Episode I by far. Atleast II had some decent/memorable parts. Hayden and Portman's acting ruined most fans view of the movie though

 

[ORDER_66]

Episode I by far. Atleast II had some decent/memorable parts. Hayden and Portman's acting ruined most fans view of the movie though

And you know what kills me the most thinking about it is Natalie Portman and Hayden C. are amazing actors, it's not THEM.... it's the DAMN SCRIPT!!!!!

 

[FlyRy]

I'll have to rewatch them but ive said before i think clones started that awful trend of like 45 min to an hour 3rd acts of boring CGI action that just becomes numbing.

But we did get the yoda scene, natalie portman looking beautiful and some really dope music from john williams

 

[Super Cheech]

Phantom

 

[Hi!]

And you know what kills me the most thinking about it is Natalie Portman and Hayden C. are amazing actors, it's not THEM.... it's the DAMN SCRIPT!!!!!

I agree I do believe they are good actors, but I can't place it entirely on the script. Ewan McGregor, Liam Neeson, and Ian McDiarmid killed their roles as Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, and Palpatine/Sidious and they had to deal with the same awful scripts

 

[Notorious 1 E.Y.E.]

As kid I liked it then one day when I was older I was like wtf . A fukking waste of an episode. Shold of just started with older anikin


I understand that star wars was always a kid/family movie but shyt. .... it was just insulting
And the midichlorians never bothered me. I actually like that it showed how bad the empire wiped the jedi out that everything known and learned was erased from history 20 years later

 

[ORDER_66]

I agree I do believe they are good actors, but I can't place it entirely on the script. Ewan McGregor, Liam Neeson, and Ian McDiarmid killed their roles as Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, and Palpatine/Sidious and they had to deal with the same awful scripts

Well what is it???? Why does only their dialogue suck???

 

[Notorious 1 E.Y.E.]

Well what is it???? Why does only their dialogue suck???

Their characters sucked, that's what the problem is