You kill me with this every time

.
No, let's be real, Uncharted 2's gameplay is >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Tomb Raider for several reasons imo.
First off, the controls and mechanics of Uncharted 2/3 are much more fluid and responsive imo than Tomb Raider. Take for instance, hanging and shooting in Uncharted 2... You can't do that in Tomb Raider. Throwing grenades while hanging.. you can't do that in TR. Climbing felt much more smooth whereas TR's animation when jumping had that sort of magnetic feel to it. I played every single game mentioned here, I've played TR for at least 20 hours.. I know how it plays and it just doesn't have that "gameplay" dudes like to bring up when comparing the two.
and please stop trolling with that "The trailer looked the same" bs you keep harping on about.
The demo shown at PSX completely destroys this nonsense.