Tracy McGrady vs Dwyane Wade

[mvp_status]

Wait wait .. TMac didnt? nikka was winning scoring titles being triple teamed night in and night out .. running with the likes of Gordon Giricek (starter) and Juwan Howard (yea THAT Juwan .. also a starter)

I didnt say he didnt

I'm saying you can't say "oh well Wade had a better team, and therefore less pressure/attention from opposing defenses", because he too was playing with shyt around him at one point and still playing at an incredible level

 

[Trust Me]

you're the one who's off track. where does it say 'peak wade vs peak tmac' in the OP? that's not what EVERYONE is talking about.

Exactly,..... this is why it shouldn't be a discussion....

Where's it say better careers?

 

[Trust Me]

I didnt say he didnt

I'm saying you can't say "oh well Wade had a better team, and therefore less pressure/attention from opposing defenses", because he too was playing with shyt around him at one point and still playing at an incredible level

That's the thing tho .. I wont argue that either. Wade's a beast. What the fukk dudes want me to say? I just think TMac was better in his peak than Wade was in his.

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Where's it say better careers?

it's tmac vs dwade - who's the better player...... you judge that on what they have proven and achieved throughout their careers... not just their peak......

if wade retired today........ who would be seen as the better player?

 

[BillBanneker]

Wade is actually a great defensive playmaker so..

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

I can clearly see you never read the thread when you said EVERYONE is talking about peak vs peak.

 

[Trust Me]

I can clearly see you never read the thread when you said EVERYONE is talking about peak vs peak.

Actually it doesnt say career OR peak. So i dont know wtf u trying to say. It simply says:

Tracy McGrady vs. Dwyane Wade


You can take it how you want and I took it how I wanted.

 

[Trust Me]

Wade is actually a great defensive playmaker so..

I'm pretty sure early on in his career (Toronto) .. when he didn't have to go out and drop 40+ every night in order for his team to win .. he was the teams defensive stopper on the wing. Remember that? Or are you too young? (No shot at you .. you really might be too young to remember .. I dont know.)

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Actually it doesnt say career OR peak. So i dont know wtf u trying to say. It simply says:

Tracy McGrady vs. Dwyane Wade


You can take it how you want and I took it how I wanted.

you just reaching for shyt to suit your argument right about now. just like you said everyone is only talking about peak vs peak.

AGAIN- if Wade retired today... who would be looked at as the better player?

 

[BillBanneker]

I'm pretty sure early on in his career (Toronto) .. when he didn't have to go out and drop 40+ every night in order for his team to win .. he was the teams defensive stopper on the wing. Remember that? Or are you too young? (No shot at you .. you really might be too young to remember .. I dont know.)

What does this have to do with him being a better defender than wade though? So he had no excuse to play d, since he wasn't the primary offensive weapon?

 

[Trust Me]

you just reaching for shyt to suit your argument right about now. just like you said everyone is only talking about peak vs peak.

AGAIN- if Wade retired today... who would be looked at as the better player?

Better player? TMac.

Better career? Wade.



Is that better?

Lets put it this way. .. nothing that Wade has ever done AS A PLAYER in his career would make me think that he's a better PLAYER than TMac. Now, if you wanna compare accomplishments ... then there's really no argument there.

 

[Trust Me]

What does this have to do with him being a better defender than wade though? So he had no excuse to play d, since he wasn't the primary offensive weapon?

Re-read what I wrote bruh. Early in his career when he wasn't relied upon to scre 40+ per game .. he could focus and play D at a high level.

When he was forced to score and carry his team .. his D suffered for it. (He didnt play much)



Make sense?

 

[Malta]

Better player? TMac.

Better career? Wade.



Is that better?

Lets put it this way. .. nothing that Wade has ever done AS A PLAYER in his career would make me think that he's a better PLAYER than TMac. Now, if you wanna compare accomplishments ... then there's really no argument there.

What exactly makes him a better player than Wade, you have yet to answer that question.

 

[BillBanneker]

Re-read what I wrote bruh. Early in his career when he wasn't relied upon to scre 40+ per game .. he could focus and play D at a high level.

When he was forced to score and carry his team .. his D suffered for it. (He didnt play much)



Make sense?

That's still no excuse. So wade hasn't had to carry the heat scoring wise? T mac has never been a great defender.

 

[PTBG]

Shooting wise=T-Mac
Pure scorer=T-Mac
Rebounder=T-Mac
Defensively, Toronto T-Mac when he was more of a defender is as good as Wade, but on a nightly basis, its Wade. But, making his teammates better you gotta give it to Wade. T-Mac was a great athlete too, but D-Wade as a athlete is outta this world and once in a lifetime type of an athlete. D-Wade is at times overrated, but he cared more about winning and more of a "killers" mentality. I'm sure if you ask any other athlete or even yourself and ask who you would wanna play with, and I'm sure most people would say Wade. Plus career wise, its no debate its Wade, but if we are going by pure skills and as a player rather than accomplishments, its a lot closer than people think, but I am actually going for Wade. Unfortunately