TSC, What Your Top 10 GOAT List Looking Like?

[TNC]

When did the fans EVER choose Nash over Sting? They got happy with Nash against Goldberg at Starrcade but that was it. He was never someone people were going nuts for or that NYGGA except for a one month build. The ENTIRE NwO angle was at first about Hogan turning heel under the premise that the WWF was invading and taking over...Hall got hot with the Survey questions and was the "cool" member as usual..Nash was doing comedy promos and burials on the mic but the fans stuck with Sting the whole way and even when they did those Surveys when the crowd was pro NwO, when Sting appeared, they turned the NwO like it wasn't shyt. LOL.

I think you quoted the wrong person brehbreh, I'm FIRMLY in the Sting >>> Nash camp

 

[R=G]

Played out HIAC match when it was the first one ever. That makes sense.

It can be the first whatever but nyggas talk about that silly match around here like it was on the Bret/Owen Mania X level.

 

[TNC]

Good grief could you at least get a room and suck his dikk in private, thanks. You cornball Rock fans are so damn butt hurt that people love HBK. The man could wrestle any style, he just has a natural physical talent.


Now anybody that doesn't agree with you isn't a wrestling fan, but a "WWE fan". Most pathetic fan base in the IWC today.

Are you a fan of wrestling or do you just skim through it?

 

[Nintendough]

Are you a fan of wrestling or do you just skim through it?

I know you dwayne fans like to show off for each other. I'm none too shocked at the fact that the potato head's stan base is doing the most derailing in this thread. Heaven forbid if somebody dares to have an opinion that doesn't fit into your view of the world right?

 

[TNC]

I know you dwayne fans like to show off for each other. I'm none too shocked at the fact that the potato head's stan base is doing the most derailing in this thread. Heaven forbid if somebody dares to have an opinion that doesn't fit into your view of the world right?

Bruh, I don't even know why you trying to pick a fight. I'm not R=G, if you got beef with him, go handle that with him but you don't need to bring it up in every thread.


That said, if you want to talk wrestling, we can do that. If you have a stance or disagree with mine, state your case and we can go from there, but I ain't got time for the bickering. So pick ya path and let's keep it moving.

 

[KEEPITTRILLA]

my list is easily the best list, and i suggest you accept my list as fact.

1. Shawn Michaels
2. Stone Cold
3. The Rock
4. Kurt Angle
5. Undertaker
6. CM Punk
7. Mick Foley
8. Triple H
9. Eddie Guerrero
10. Flair/Hogan

HM: X-Pac, Y2J, Daniel Bryan

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

Dude you are talking booking right now. Nash at NO point in time was bigger than Sting.

Yes the NWO was the biggest angle in WCW (arguably wrestling) history, but no ONE person gets credit for that, it was a team effort. But the NWO angle itself was built around Sting as much as anyone else not named Hogan. Who was the main hero against thw NWO heels? Sting

Nash was very over and is much more charismatic than Steve Borden is as a person, but people were not paying to see him work. Even look at it now, people are BEGGING the WWE to get Sting, even in his current Larry Holmes form, at WrestleMania at least one time. Are people clamoring for Nash anywhere?

And for the record, Sting will be over in ANY area he goes to, he is a legit living legend in this business

1. Debatable. Nash was pretty damn over and people were hating on Goldberg not only because they were tired of him, but also because they wanted to see Nash win the strap. Its not just like they hated Goldberg and Nash just happened to be the guy.
2. The direct comment I was responding to was R=G saying Sting means much much more to wrestling history than Nash. The Outsiders crashing WCW was a super hot angle and the Bash at the Beach Hogan turn propelled it to astronomic levels. Nash was more in the forefront aside from the Crow angle, though Sting was a major player...and he wasnt exactly always the main hero. The Horsemen, Macho, Goldberg and DDP also played a role as WCW representatives vs the nWo..it wasnt just Sting. That was a team effort too. Sting's peak against them topped anyone elses probably (Crow vs Goldberg idk).. but he also declared himself to be a free agent, and the allure of the Crow Sting was that he was basically unaffiliated (picking and choosing his battles), then chose the Wolfpac.
3. Charisma and mic work doesnt play a role in comparisons? To each their own. But it's worth noting that the Jackknife was over as fukk and people enjoyed seeing him tag with Hall. Im not too sure people were paying to see Sting work in the ring all that much either (Crow used the bat more than HHH used the sledgehammer), but he is admittedly the better worker. Not debating that.
4. People want to see Sting in the WWE because its uncharted territory and he is a legend. Im not debating that either. Id have Sting in my Top 15. But you have to recognize that they don't want the TNA Sting that they currently have now ..(Main Event Mafia? ) It'd have to probably be enigmatic Crow Sting, and it would have to be a very short run. People aren't clamoring for Nash anymore because theyve seen him in the E a lot (and the E botched the nWo poison injection)...he was fairly over during that run and remained over in the Elim Chamber match. He also got a huge pop as Diesel. People were intrigued with his latest run (although smarks have always been sick with him) even though it was random as fukk and until booking ruined the hell out of it and made it outrageously unproductive it wasn't all that bad. They were never going to give Nash full freedom on the mic like he had when he was very over in WCW..and even though he seemed rusty, he still dropped the classic short order cook line. Crow Sting would be easier to integrate, and people recognize this. Sting and Undertaker always drew the most inter-fed comparisons from decades past..
5. How over has Sting been in TNA? People paying to see him work? The people just want to see a Crow Sting run against Taker just to see what would happen with the E machine behind him for the first and only time.

 

[CM_Burns]

Sting was called a horrible draw but Sting damn sure means MUCH, MUCH more to wrestling history than Nash. Even if it was a NwO legacy thing, Hall was the more liked between them. Hell, he started the hot angle to begin with. Nash vs Goldberg was NOWHERE near as Sting vs Hogan Goldberg was already losing popularity at this point...they were chanting Goldberg SUCKS at that point. Nah..that's crazy. If he was facing Goldberg mid 98, it would of been bigger.

Does really clearly mean more than Nash though? Pre-96 Sting is not as important in history as Lex Luger, who consistently drew better than him during those NWA/WCW years. If we're judging them by their monday night wars runs, its pretty close.

Nash vs Goldbeeg was a big deal, it sold like 650k while Sting/Hogan sold 750k. Sting/Hogan had a whole year building to it, and had to compete against HBK vs Shamrock for PPV money, Nash/Goldberg competed against Rock/Mankind and Austin/McMahon feud at its hottest. For all they say "Starrcade is WCWs Wrestlemania", it wasn't. The gate and PPV it did was serious for WCW and not something guaranteed for the show like Mania. TThe Sting/Flair/Hogan headlined ones had usually been doing 300-400k.

 

[Plexxx]

Stone Cold
Savage
Shawn Michaels
The Rock
Kurt Angle
Undertaker
Eddie Guerrero
Hogan
Sting
CM Punk

 

[AKM-95]

Ric Flair
Bret Hart
Stone Cold
Razor Ramon
Kurt Angle
Hulk Hogan/Hollywood Hogan
Undertaker
The Rock
Macho Man
Sting
HM
Shawn Michaels,RVD, Samoa Joe, Mr.Perfect, Y2J

 

[ryda518]

1-Stone Cold
2-Stone Cold
3-Stone Cold
4-Stone Cold
5-Stone Cold
6-Stone Cold
7-Stone Cold
8-Stone Cold
9-Stone Cold
10-Stone Cold
11-Orton

problem?

 

[Silkk]

1-Stone Cold
2-Stone Cold
3-Stone Cold
4-Stone Cold
5-Stone Cold
6-Stone Cold
7-Stone Cold
8-Stone Cold
9-Stone Cold
10-Stone Cold
11-Orton

problem?

Thats 11

 

[ryda518]

Thats 11

1-Stone Cold
2-Stone Cold
3-Stone Cold
4-Stone Cold
5-Stone Cold
6-Stone Cold
7-Stone Cold
8-Stone Cold
9-Stone Cold
10-Stone Cold

 

[I-Hate-You]

Stone Cole Steve Austin or Stone Cold Paul Wight?

 

[lutha]

i'm not really into list so there is no order, but i'll name 10:

Hogan
flair/4 horseman
road warriors
rock
macho man
dusty
sting
taker
Austin
hbk

*if I cant include the 4 horseman with flair, they'd replace Austin*

...this is why I don't like lists, cause it's so many I didn't include:

the midnight express
rock and roll express
the von eriks
piper
rick rude
honkey tonk man
mr perfect
bret hart
Goldberg
y2j
nash
booker t