TSC, What Your Top 10 GOAT List Looking Like?

[Juanito]

List of my favorites

1. Y2J
2. Rock
3. Austin
4. Taker
5. HBK
6. Eddie G
7. Ric Flair
8. HHH
9. Bret Hart
10. Kurt Angle

Hard to really leave out some but growing up the Attitude Era was dope for sure. Punk and Bryan are some of my favorites now but def not top 10 yet

 

[AJW]

I started watching in around '97 and never watched WCW that much (wasn't aired much over here). Due to that, my top ten are:

1. HBK the GOAT
2. Stone Cold
3. The Rock
4. Undertaker
5. Punk
6. Triple H
7. Chris Jericho
8. Brock Lesnar
9. Kurt Angle
10. Edge

I spent far too much time making that list.

 

[Swag King Cole]

no particular order

1.HBK
2.Bryan Danielson
3.Undertaker
4.Eddie Guerrero
5.El Generico
6.Human Tornado
7.Chris Jericho
8.Rob Van Dam
9.CM Punk
10.El Santo
11.Chris Benoit

 

[mikishere]

Rock
Austin
HBK
HHH
Scott Hall
Y2J
Taker
Hogan
Flair
Eddie

 

[R=G]

Nash > Sting on the mic
Nash nWo run more historically important (put wcw over) than Sting crow run (prob his peak), especially considering Sting as the crow was predicated on what he would do in regards to the nWo. No nWo, no Crow Sting.
Flair was arguably more over than Sting in the 4 horsemen so downplaying Nash due to Hall isnt on point when contrasting him with Sting. Plus, Hall and Nash as a combo > anything Sting did in tag matches.
Nash held both big belts

Sting needs to have a run with WWE and have his match with Taker, then we'll talk.

All that said, I dont have them very far apart in my rankings but that specific comment is off base.

Lol

 

[R=G]

So you just making up shyt now?

Hahaha

 

[R=G]

Lol@people who name Bret and Michaels all saying "fukk who drew money". Yeah right..if it wasnt for the Hogans, Austins, Rocks, Andres, MachoMans....Bret and Michsels wouldn't exist. Wouldn't have a platform. They damn sure wasn't good enough to lead to build a company off of. Saying theyre better than Savage is like saying Kofi is better than Taker. Absolutely absurd. If drawing money didnt mean shyt...u wouldn't even mention it as a factor.

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

Lol@people who name Bret and Michaels all saying "fukk who drew money". Yeah right..if it wasnt for the Hogans, Austins, Rocks, Andres, MachoMans....Bret and Michsels wouldn't exist. Wouldn't have a platform. They damn sure wasn't good enough to lead to build a company off of. Saying theyre better than Savage is like saying Kofi is better than Taker. Absolutely absurd. If drawing money didnt mean shyt...u wouldn't even mention it as a factor.

I agree on this. I was going to put Andre on my list but I never really had the chance to watch him personally..though I was very aware of his history as a young kid. I think many proponents of Bret and HBK are including in ring ability in addition to popularity and being a slight/average draw. I def have Savage over them though.

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

Lol

You think the crow run would be as hot without the nWo?

or he would blow up as much without the 4 horsemen?

The latter is arguable but I dont think you can argue against the first point very much.

 

[CJ]

Lol@people who name Bret and Michaels all saying "fukk who drew money". Yeah right..if it wasnt for the Hogans, Austins, Rocks, Andres, MachoMans....Bret and Michsels wouldn't exist. Wouldn't have a platform. They damn sure wasn't good enough to lead to build a company off of. Saying theyre better than Savage is like saying Kofi is better than Taker. Absolutely absurd. If drawing money didnt mean shyt...u wouldn't even mention it as a factor.

These are personal top 10s. They can be for whatever reason you want. If we want to exclude draws, we can. Otherwise every list would be the damn same and defeat the purpose then.

 

[R=G]

Cool. Just dont mention drawing as a reason as a spin for justification....several just did.

 

[R=G]

You think the crow run would be as hot without the nWo?

or he would blow up as much without the 4 horsemen?

The latter is arguable but I dont think you can argue against the first point very much.

The NwO was a storyline builder but Sting was more over than anything that WCW was offering at the time. No one was touching him...those pops were blowing away Austin's and everyone else's in the business.

 

[Rarely-Wrong Liggins]

Randy Savage of course, just too many GOAT runs in both organizations
Hogan
Austin
HHH
Cena
Bryan
Goldust, this dude is fukking durable, deal with it
Eddie Guerrero
Kane
Taker

 

[Nintendough]

Golddust/Dustin Rhodes should be on more lists. I wont bytch and moan about others opinions like certain people but that is a name I should see more. He always performed in the ring at an elite level and his promo skills are top 20 all time easily.

 

[Batter Up]

Cool. Just dont mention drawing as a reason as a spin for justification....several just did.

The thread got derailed into a debate about drawing power which is why people started prefacing their lists saying they don't care about that shyt. Believe it or not there's other factors that are more important to some fans then how much money a wrestler made for a company they don't work for.