Vick was a trendsetter but I do find it funny how Vick stans act like he invented the concept of being a dual threat QB as if Randall and Steve Young didn't exist.
I hate how Cunningham has completely been erased from history as if he wasn't one of the trailblazers for black QBs and doesn't have an All-Pro 1st team and MVP on his resume unlike Vick.
Same shyt with McNabb who carried bums for most of his career but doesn't get a fraction of the love Mike does.
This happens a lot in sports, and other fields of entertainment for that matter.
People (often young) will think that something is new and unprecedented, when there are numerous examples of it happening before that. The NFL has been around for so long, what are the chances of someone in fairly recent years really being the first one to do something?
RBs who can run and catch is another example. I often hear people crediting certain RBs for bringing that into the game. It’s gotten more common in the last couple of decades, but it’s always been there. Marshall Faulk had 1,000/1,000 on GSOT, as did Roger Craig in 1985. Craig’s career also intersected with dual threats like Marcus Allen, Thurman Thomas, and Walter Payton. There was Joe Washington, Chuck Foreman, Lydell Mitchell, etc…back in the 70s. The 50s had Lenny Moore & Frank Gifford.
The claim with Vick is especially strange given the time frame (drafted in 01’). The NFL was already shifting in this direction in the previous few years, with a bunch of big names and early draft picks being dual threat QBs.
McNair was picked 3rd overall in the 95’ draft and led the 99’ Titans to a Super Bowl appearance. McNabb was the 2nd overall pick in 99’ and MVP runner up in 00’. Culpepper was picked in the first round in 99’ and had a Pro Bowl season in 00’. Young had already been arguably the best QB of the 90s.
There were other QBs like Slash and Mark Brunell… even Doug Flutie returning to the NFL after his CFL success. The 70s had Bobby Douglas, Fran Tarkenton, Steve Grogan, Greg Landry, etc…
What I do think was different about Vick was just how remarkably fast he was. He wasn’t just “fast for a QB”. He was fast for any position, which gave defensive coordinators something extra to think about.
I’m glad you mentioned Cunningham, as he was one of my favorite players at the time.
I think Cunningham and Vick had some career similarities, such as having their best passing seasons (1998, 2010) after they had been away from the sport. I think both of them admitted to not studying film earlier in their careers like they should have, and then doing it more later in their careers when they had their best passing seasons. It also obviously helped Randall that the Vikings had an amazing receiving corps.
But Cunningham still had some good passing seasons before that, particularly in 90’. He probably should have won MVP that year . While rushing for nearly 1,000 yards, he led the NFC in touchdown passes. Then the next year, he tore his ACL on a play similar to Tom Brady/Carson Palmer’s ACL injuries.
I wish he had a different HC than Buddy Ryan, who apparently told him “make 5 big plays and our defense will take care of the rest”. Buddy was a great DC but not much as a Head Coach.
The people complaining about Twitter probably just think about how Vick was on Madden, or just remember the highlight reels and not how much he struggled as a passer for most of his career.