Wait, hold up. Why isn't Jason Campbell a starter in the league this year?

[JLova]

J.T 'Just Turnovers' O'Sullivan, really? He was never better than Alex Smith, like I said poor decision. But I'll concede to Shaun Hill, but even then in extended play, it was shown that while he made better decisions than Alex Smith, he had a weaker arm and virtually no athleticism.

Again throwing for more yardage is pointless if you throw more picks and even in JC's best season he threw for 500 more yards, not nearly enough to justify the 10 more INTs, he threw. Put it like this if JC were our QB we would have lost the Lions, the Seahawks and we likely wouldn't have even beat the Giants in the regular season we'd be lucky to be 10-6 fighting for a Wild Card. Under the Harbaugh offense I'll take heat pump efficiency over a stronger arm. I well say this the upcoming season will etch Alex's legacy in stone, was he a mismanaged #1 draft or will he forever be a marginal starter/backup.

Got damn, read!!!

I never said JTO was better. Point to an area where I said he was better or even implied it. All I said was JTO was handpicked by Martz to come in and compete for the job. At the beginning of TC before Alex got hurt....JT was top dog because he knew the offense while Hill and Smith struggled. Smith struggled the most.

Alex was mismanaged but he's not good either. QB's are not one in the same that are only separated by good coaching and weapons. LOL.

picks suck, but so do 3 and outs. More yardage tends to mean you're moving the ball more. 9er fans have really bought into this stupid "small ball" QBing we saw last year.

 

[JLova]

Jason Campbell could probably start over Fez in NY and if I had to choose I'd take Campbell, but the marginal improvement at QB probably wouldn't be enough to make me feel comfortable at QB anyway, and that's the position Jason Campbell is in with the league. The improvement from any random QB to him isn't so wide that it's worth investing into him.

I know....which is why I said Cambpell is better than several QB's. However, the circumstances hurt him because it doesn't make sense for some teams to get rid of their starters for him.

Arizona... They paid Kolb a wack of money.
SF... Cambpell is pretty much the same player as Smith...no point in making that moe
Jets... Fez isn't going to get dumped after the $ investment.
Jags, Vikes.. Rookie QBs who I think suck, but they're not going to make that move
Seattle...maybe a fit...but the unproven Flynn was younger and had hype.

 

[ahomeplateslugger]

On any other team, Alex Smith is long gone......but for whatever reason, he's stuck around in SF. It's an incredibly unique situation that probably shouldn't be compared to that of any other below-average QB.

word around town is that alex smith and jed york got a thing going on

 

[mastermind]

I know....which is why I said Cambpell is better than several QB's. However, the circumstances hurt him because it doesn't make sense for some teams to get rid of their starters for him.

Arizona... They paid Kolb a wack of money.
SF... Cambpell is pretty much the same player as Smith...no point in making that moe
Jets... Fez isn't going to get dumped after the $ investment.
Jags, Vikes.. Rookie QBs who I think suck, but they're not going to make that move
Seattle...maybe a fit...but the unproven Flynn was younger and had hype.

yeah, this is how I feel too but I understand it. There is no conspiracy with why he isnt starting. He just isnt good.

 

[Born2BKing]

yeah, this is how I feel too but I understand it. There is no conspiracy with why he isnt starting. He just isnt good.

So a career qb rating in line with some well known starters = he sucks. Boy I tell ya. A black QB in the NFL can either be great or terrible.

 

[JLova]

yeah, this is how I feel too but I understand it. There is no conspiracy with why he isnt starting. He just isnt good.

Yea...I never said there was one...but I got lumped into that group.

 

[mastermind]

So a career qb rating in line with some well known starters = he sucks. Boy I tell ya. A black QB in the NFL can either be great or terrible.

Yea...I never said there was one...but I got lumped into that group.

fair enough.

 

[Maschine_Man]

So a career qb rating in line with some well known starters = he sucks. Boy I tell ya. A black QB in the NFL can either be great or terrible.

stop trolling and start using some sense

where exactly should Campbell be starting right now?

Don't just come out and ask why isn't he starting..
come out and say where and why he should be starting on _______

You dudes are killing me with these threads. If you can't logically give an explanation or a reason to make a thread then why bother trolling with this racist crap?


Why isn't Kyle Orton starting in the NFL?

Orton is just as good or maybe even better than Campbell but he ain't starting


shyt, IMO those two guys are mirror images of each other. But had chances to start, both showed what they really are and proved that right now in their careers they are no more than just solid back up qb's that can come in when needed and maybe lead the team to a win or two.

The NFL is a qb driven league now, and teams would rather take a chance on a young gun that has potential to be the next brady or manning then to stay with the status quo on average guys like orton or Campbell

b-b-b-b-b-but....if Campbell was white.....

 

[Born2BKing]

stop trolling and start using some sense

where exactly should Campbell be starting right now?

Don't just come out and ask why isn't he starting..
come out and say where and why he should be starting on _______

You dudes are killing me with these threads. If you can't logically give an explanation or a reason to make a thread then why bother trolling with this racist crap?


Why isn't Kyle Orton starting in the NFL?

Orton is just as good or maybe even better than Campbell but he ain't starting


shyt, IMO those two guys are mirror images of each other. But had chances to start, both showed what they really are and proved that right now in their careers they are no more than just solid back up qb's that can come in when needed and maybe lead the team to a win or two.

The NFL is a qb driven league now, and teams would rather take a chance on a young gun that has potential to be the next brady or manning then to stay with the status quo on average guys like orton or Campbell

b-b-b-b-b-but....if Campbell was white.....

nikka did you not see the other posts I've made in this thread?

 

[Maschine_Man]

nikka did you not see the other posts I've made in this thread?

I have yet to see anyone in this thread make a solid argument for why he should be starting in this league and where


make it happen bruh.....I'm waiting

or just admit that you got a little to homotional over some average ass black qb and didn't bother looking at the reality of the situation....

 

[Born2BKing]

I have yet to see anyone in this thread make a solid argument for why he should be starting in this league and where


make it happen bruh.....I'm waiting

or just admit that you got a little to homotional over some average ass black qb and didn't bother looking at the reality of the situation....

nikka played with the Raiders and Redskins and still has a solid qb rating and only has 2 losing seasons in 7 years. He could beast in a solid organization.

 

[Maschine_Man]

nikka played with the Raiders and Redskins and still has a solid qb rating and only has 2 losing seasons in 7 years. He could beast in a solid organization.

That sounds great, but tell me WHAT teams would be better of with Campbell starting right now.

I don't care what he did and where he played before now. Just tell me what teams he should be starting on right now instead of the player they currently have at the moment.

and LOTS of players would beast in a solid organization. Shyt, if Alex Smith came up in NE, Philly, GB or Pittsburgh I guarantee he'd be 10x better than he is now.

but the reality is, right now JC is a 31 year old qb that has only played 2 full season in the league. Has never shown to be an above average qb ever in his career.

 

[tremonthustler1]

. A QB in the NFL can either be great or terrible.

Fixed that for you. Nobody wants their QB to just be aight. It's one of the few positions in football where it's hard to get away with an OK QB.

 

[JLova]

That sounds great, but tell me WHAT teams would be better of with Campbell starting right now.

I don't care what he did and where he played before now. Just tell me what teams he should be starting on right now instead of the player they currently have at the moment.

and LOTS of players would beast in a solid organization. Shyt, if Alex Smith came up in NE, Philly, GB or Pittsburgh I guarantee he'd be 10x better than he is now.

but the reality is, right now JC is a 31 year old qb that has only played 2 full season in the league. Has never shown to be an above average qb ever in his career.

 

[Mr swag]

Cardinals - No, John Skelton is 24 years old and can only improve, he's arguably better than Kevin Kolb, so no

Vikings - No argument here

Jaguars - This team lives off the running game and a tough Defense, also, they are still trying to figure out Blaine Gabbert, they gave him an extremely talent but troubled rookie to throw the ball to, so no.

San Francisco - Alex Smith is better than Jason Campell, I'll take a QB that throws for 18 TD and 5 int over a QB that gives me 20 TD 15 INT his best season, besides Alex is 2-3 years younger and still has a little upside, also Alex Smith the the more mobile QB so no, Injuries will have forced Jason Campbell to stay in the pocket and with SF at times iffy pass blocking, dude will go out on a cart.

Seahawks - I'll give that but Russel Wilson is balling out of control and they got Matt Flynn, so no.

So no Jason Cambell has few if any places he can really start anymore.

Slekon CAN'T GET BETTER CUZ HIS NOT ANY GOOD

LOL at alex smith. Classic case of a guy having a good team which in turn makes the qb any good. You leave out the fact SF tired to sign other people