You can't pull one post or line in this thread where I say Wale isn't a good rapper. I agree, his projects haven't been terrible. Some have been underwhelming, but nothing has been completely trash. I'm fully aware of his discography... but when you look at his status in hiphop and where he feels he's at... he's not even happy with it.
I agree that he's versatile. He has and can make a wide range of songs well. I think we all can agree that he makes the introspective relationship/woman appreciation song best... he makes great soulful music when he chooses to. It's not about pigeonholing him, I'm making an observation and saying... his versatility just might be a part of why he hasn't leveled up in the game like his peers have.
In your opinion, why has J. Cole and Big Sean surpassed him status/acclaim/sales wise in the game right now?
Big Sean doesn't have more sales than Wale in their careers. Wale has been more consistent.
Wale
Ambition = Debuted #2, went Gold
Gifted = Debuted #1, went Gold
TAAN = Debuted #1, but most likely Gold
Big Sean
Finally Famous = Debuted #3, not sure of status
Hall of Fame = Debuted #3, not sure of status, but it came out in 2013 and has sold 155k ad of 2015, so probably not gold
Dark Sky Paradise = Debuted #1, Gold
I Decided = Debuted #1, Gold
Very few rap artists are even going gold in this day and age, so both being able to move those units shows a dedicated fan base.
As for acclaim, Big Sean's albums DEFINITELY aren't more acclaimed than Wale's. They both have an average metacritic score of 70 (not that anyone should give a shyt about this). It's a wash if anything. Wale is very obviously a more skilled emcee with more versatile content, but whatever.
I'm extremely happy for J.Cole. He's a good dude with a good message and a pretty good rapper too. Wale not being on Cole's level isn't anything to critique. Cole, Kendrick and Drake are the only tier 1 rappers of their generation. Nobody else compares, but great careers exist in that second tier - which is where both Wale and Big Sean are. Wale should learn to be okay with that at this point in his career. He's 4 albums deep and a 10 year veteran. At that point, you are what you are.
We are both fans of a rapper who we (or at least I) feel is the best rapper on the planet. None of these dudes are fukking with his discography or his talent, but he's what at this point? A tier 4 rapper at best? While it sucks Lupe doesn't get that recognition, sometimes the stars just don't align (personality that is too polarizing, label issues, not having a marketable image/gimmick) for an artist to be a SUPERSTAR. To be one takes into account so much more than just the music and artistry.
I honestly feel Wale's lack of success (only compared to the tier 1 guys) has absolutely nothing to do with his content. His image and personality just isn't as marketable, but he has a solidified lane with women and has carved out a great career for himself. I would be THRILLED if Lupe had the same level of sales and recognizability right now as Wale does.
Lastly, as a Wale fan, I greatly appreciate his versatility. I doubt the answer to his lack of comparative success is "narrow your lane", but even if it was, I wouldn't want him to do that, and I doubt he would too. In fact, when he tried to narrow his lane with Ambition, his core fan base didn't fukk with it at all.
PS: I just heard Fashion Week and think the song is dope besides the G-Eazy verse.