TheGreatMTB
All Star
Claymore is one of my favorite manga (I got the box set) and they do have similarities, it's clear there was some inspiration. But I believe AoT has better plot twists and better execution of some story beats. With some story work and if Wit adapted it, Claymore would make some noise in 2022, but...If you grew up with shyt like Gantz and Claymore, AoT really ain't anything new outside of the Titans as a type of bizarre adversary and the maneuver gear.
shyt, since we're talking adaptations - AoT's animation was so far ahead of the manga's art at the time that its actually ridiculous and unfair to other projects who deserved better from the start.
Using your logic, once you reach a certain age no story (anime, manga, live action, etc) is impressive, as storytelling is essentially the same. That's why I focus on execution, and I believe AoT's execution (at least what's been adapted so far) is top tier.
Also Gantz is severely overhyped. I'm about to go read Claymore again.




