Who has the better legacy: Donovan McNabb or Mike Vick?

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

It's bigger than football. You embarrass all black people with this blasphemy.

I will make sure to add Vick to the mount rushmore of the most important African Americans in US history right along with MLK, Malcolm, Obama , Oprah and......Vick

 

[Tha Gawd Amen]

exactly!!! I always argued that point..bc everyone white and black used to trash Donovan..he was my guy...even tho he was corny as fukk and he loved throwing worm burners ( balls at ya feet) I think if he has the WR talent Vick has been afforded...he would have seen a few more SB appearances

I trash him for throwing balls at people's feet and being too much of a company man, but once he got a great WR, I saw results.

People forget our defense choked in a lot of those NFC championship games and it wasn't just on McNabb's shoulders. If only Jackson and Maclin came sooner

But I don't think Vick (unless you're talking about eagles Vick) had too much receiver talent in Atlanta outside of Crumpler.

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

I trash him for throwing balls at people's feet and being too much of a company man, but once he got a great WR, I saw results.

People forget our defense choked in a lot of those NFC championship games and it wasn't just on McNabb's shoulders. If only Jackson and Maclin came sooner

But I don't think Vick (unless you're talking about eagles Vick) had too much receiver talent in Atlanta outside of Crumpler.

I mean Vick in Philly not ATL..in atlanta his WR were straight trash....

 

[BelowTheMasonDixon]

One is a hall of famer and the other is a felon.

 

[Ohene]

mcnabb is better but the Vick flash and electricity is why hell be remembered more. He changed the game

 

[Ohene]

When Donovan threw this pass I thought we were going back to the Super Bowl. Arizona played hard but Philly VS Pittsburgh would of been so EPIC:

Man fukk that season. That one takes the fukkin cake of most disappointing seasons. shyt was a roller coaster. I really thought we were winning it all after that turnaround. We fukking thrashed the Cardinals on monday night earlier that season

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

Man fukk that season. That one takes the fukkin cake of most disappointing seasons. shyt was a roller coaster. I really thought we were winning it all after that turnaround. We fukking thrashed the Cardinals on monday night earlier that season

i remember that shyt like it was yesterday..noone thought the cards were winning...everyone punches the eagles into the SB that year

 

[Carlos Huerta]

mcnabb is better but the Vick flash and electricity is why hell be remembered more. He changed the game

He didn't change a damn thing. The Coli is full of so many sports retards it's laughable. The thread is a good example.

Like dude said, one is a HOFer and the other is a felon. Those are their legacies.

 

[Ohene]

i remember that shyt like it was yesterday..noone thought the cards were winning...everyone punches the eagles into the SB that year

Eagles are the fukking worst

 

[RubioTheCruel]

McNabb, as soon as he had an elite WR he got his team to the SB.

 

[Ohene]

He didn't change a damn thing. The Coli is full of so many sports retards it's laughable. The thread is a good example.

Like dude said, one is a HOFer and the other is a felon. Those are their legacies.

man fukk outta here. Watching Michael Vick in 2010 after Kevin Kolb went down...that was the greatest season of any QB i've ever witnessed. Call me a stan or whatever i give zero fukks. There wasnt another more entertaining, electrifying season as that one in my 22 year life.

 

[NYSTATEOFMIND]

McNabb, as soon as he had an elite WR he got his team to the SB.

buh buh buh Vick is a "real nikka" tho

 

[Ohene]

unbelievable football

 

[Rapmastermind]

Man fukk that season. That one takes the fukkin cake of most disappointing seasons. shyt was a roller coaster. I really thought we were winning it all after that turnaround. We fukking thrashed the Cardinals on monday night earlier that season

It hurt but it was still a Classic season. To beat the Defending Champs Giants in Their house in th Playoffs. 44-6 blowing out Dallas. Having the Tie game that caused controversy actually be the reason we made the playoffs.Blowing the doors off Arizona on Thanksgiving. The Donovan Benching. I think they could seriously do a TV Movie about the Eagles during the Mcnabb/Reid era. I mean the stars were alining. I don't know what happen in the NFC title game. All the sudden our Defense who was playing lightsout couldn't stop anyone.

That was Jim Johnson's last game, he died that summer. That was the most heartbreaking NFC Title loss of the 4. Carolina they hurt Donovan Early. Tampa wanted revenge, just like the Cardinals did. They took the greatest show on turf to the brink in the NFC Title game but they were young. Two of Warner's Superbowl berth's came through Mcnabb's Eagles. Matter a fact during Mcnabb's reign you had to go through the Eagles to get to the Superbowl. It was kinda cool they put the seal on that Legendary year as it was the backdrop for that Oscar winning film "Silver Lining Playbook". Had we beat the cards I really think we would of gave the Steelers a run for their money. We beat them earlier that year too.

 

[Fart Knocker]

I'm a Vick fan but mcnabb is the answer and it isn't close