Who was better? Paul Pierce or Carmelo Anthony

[YoungMoneyCashMoneyBoy]

fukk Paul Pierce


If Kevin McHale doesn't gift Ainge with KG, nobody is even talking about punk ass pierce. When he was the best player on the team, they had losing seasons and early playoff exits.

Benzino should've finished the job that night in the club

When melo was the best player on a better team, all he did was lose in the first round. Melo had 5 first round exits in a row and 8 in his first 9 years with better teams.

Pierce led the celtics to the ECF once - the same amount of times melo led the nuggets to the WCF - with lesser talent.

Pierce brought the celtics as far in the East as Melo did in the west, but melo had billups, jr, kenyon and nene while pierce had antoine and the ghost of kenny anderson

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

When melo was the best player on a better team, all he did was lose in the first round. Melo had 5 first round exits in a row and 8 in his first 9 years with better teams.

Pierce led the celtics to the ECF once - the same amount of times melo led the nuggets to the WCF - with lesser talent.

Pierce brought the celtics as far in the East as Melo did in the west, but melo had billups, jr, kenyon and nene while pierce had antoine and the ghost of kenny anderson

And rodney rogers rip

 

[Homeboy Runny-Ray]

Paul pierce had a better career and was a better all around player. Me lo came to the league with more hype and a much bigger fan base due to his early rivalry with Bron.

because of his early rivalry with bron??

nevermind the fact that he just won the national title and was the true national player of the year??

 

[KevCo]

yall need to cut the bullchit.

aint nobody in their right mind finna take pierce over melo as their franchise player.​

Someone took Darko over Melo tho

 

[Homeboy Runny-Ray]

When melo was the best player on a better team, all he did was lose in the first round. Melo had 5 first round exits in a row and 8 in his first 9 years with better teams.

Pierce led the celtics to the ECF once - the same amount of times melo led the nuggets to the WCF - with lesser talent.

Pierce brought the celtics as far in the East as Melo did in the west, but melo had billups, jr, kenyon and nene while pierce had antoine and the ghost of kenny anderson

youre comparing different conferences & different eras.

replace melo with pierce on most of those nuggets squads and youre getting multiple 9th & 10th place finishes.

Someone took Darko over Melo tho

in fairness, they needed a PF and the Darko hype was outrageous.

I knew dude was gonna flop tho.

 

[stepbackj34spud]

When melo was the best player on a better team, all he did was lose in the first round. Melo had 5 first round exits in a row and 8 in his first 9 years with better teams.

Pierce led the celtics to the ECF once - the same amount of times melo led the nuggets to the WCF - with lesser talent.

Pierce brought the celtics as far in the East as Melo did in the west, but melo had billups, jr, kenyon and nene while pierce had antoine and the ghost of kenny anderson

Gospel son. nikkas don’t realize. Pierce played with fukking trash. Last time he was in the playoffs before the big 3 he had a fukking washed up Antoine Walker and washed up Gary Payton. I am sleeeeeep. Melo has played with way better talent and did way less.

 

[stepbackj34spud]

youre comparing different conferences & different eras.

replace melo with pierce on most of those nuggets squads and youre getting multiple 9th & 10th place finishes.





in fairness, they needed a PF and the Darko hype was outrageous.

I knew dude was gonna flop tho.

youre comparing different conferences & different eras.

replace melo with pierce on most of those nuggets squads and youre getting multiple 9th & 10th place finishes.





in fairness, they needed a PF and the Darko hype was outrageous.

I knew dude was gonna flop tho.

Whose mans is this? Nobody believes this but you. You put prime Pierce And Melo on the same team, you’re gonna win way more games with Pierce instead of Melo.

I’m kinda sick of arguing Pierce vs one dimensional ass Melo.

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

When melo was the best player on a better team, all he did was lose in the first round. Melo had 5 first round exits in a row and 8 in his first 9 years with better teams.

Pierce led the celtics to the ECF once - the same amount of times melo led the nuggets to the WCF - with lesser talent.

Pierce brought the celtics as far in the East as Melo did in the west, but melo had billups, jr, kenyon and nene while pierce had antoine and the ghost of kenny anderson

Melo led his squads in Denver to 3 division titles and 3 50 win seasons.

How many division titles or 50 win seasons did Boston have with Pierce as the #1

I also like how y'all nikkas always forget how trash the Eastern Conference was then when Pierce was in Boston

 

[YoungMoneyCashMoneyBoy]

Melo led his squads in Denver to 3 division titles and 3 50 win seasons.

How many division titles or 50 win seasons did Boston have with Pierce as the #1

I also like how y'all nikkas always forget how trash the Eastern Conference was then when Pierce was in Boston

8 out of 9 first round exits. Pierce won when he got all star teammates. Melo choked. Give pierce AI or Chauncey, kenyon, camby, etc and he'd make it to the playoffs every year too.

All that talent and made it as far as pierce did in the east.

 

[Homeboy Runny-Ray]

Melo led his squads in Denver to 3 division titles and 3 50 win seasons.

How many division titles or 50 win seasons did Boston have with Pierce as the #1

I also like how y'all nikkas always forget how trash the Eastern Conference was then when Pierce was in Boston

THIS.

melo's teams had bad luck draws in the playoffs but their track record was impressive.

pierce wasn't winning nothing in the trash east. only time he went far was in '02 when he wasn't even the clear-cut #1 option. him and walker were 1A/1B.

8 out of 9 first round exits. Pierce won when he got all star teammates. Melo choked. Give pierce AI or Chauncey, kenyon, camby, etc and he'd make it to the playoffs every year too.

All that talent and made it as far as pierce did in the east.

melo didn't choke.
the nuggets just got bad draws.
paul pierce aint leading no team to a series win over the spurs or lakers, who went on to either win the west or win the whole NBA in those years.​

put melo on the celtics and they win the title in '10 despite kendrick going down.​

and they at least get to the finals in '09 without KG.​

hell, they get at least one win over miami and might get another ring after that.​

 

[Derek Lee]

Pierce is better (by a small margin). Deal with it Melo stans

 

[YoungMoneyCashMoneyBoy]

THIS.

melo's teams had bad luck draws in the playoffs but their track record was impressive.

pierce wasn't winning nothing in the trash east. only time he went far was in '02 when he wasn't even the clear-cut #1 option. him and walker were 1A/1B.

melo didn't choke.
the nuggets just got bad draws.
paul pierce aint leading no team to a series win over the spurs or lakers, who went on to either win the west or win the whole NBA in those years.​

put melo on the celtics and they win the title in '10 despite kendrick going down.
and they at least get to the finals in '09 without KG.
hell, they get at least one win over miami and might get another ring after that.​

He led the celtics over the lakers team that swept melo's team in the first round. Melo had A.I., jr smith, kenyon and camby. Melo choked (22 ppg on 36% shooting).

Not going back and forth on this. You can have the last word.

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

8 out of 9 first round exits. Pierce won when he got all star teammates. Melo choked. Give pierce AI or Chauncey, kenyon, camby, etc and he'd make it to the playoffs every year too.

All that talent and made it as far as pierce did in the east.

Who did Melo choke to?

All but one of his first round exits he lost to the eventual champ or #1 seed. Melo just got bad luck with seeding in a historically tough conference

Pierce isnt getting Denver past the Lakers or Spurs either

 

[Kairi Irving]

Melo is more talented

Pierce has B-ball IQ

I'd choose Pierce because he's easier to play with and never was a locker room cancer or a hindrance to his teammates.

 

[Homeboy Runny-Ray]

He led the celtics over the lakers team that swept melo's team in the first round. Melo had A.I., jr smith, kenyon and camby. Melo choked (22 ppg on 36% shooting).

Not going back and forth on this. You can have the last word.

lol

paul pierce aint lead chit.

that was KG's team.

Melo is more talented

Pierce has B-ball IQ

I'd choose Pierce because he's easier to play with and never was a locker room cancer or a hindrance to his teammates.

where are you getting this from?

melo was never considered a locker room cancer or hinderance by anyone who actually played with him.

and paul pierce used to jack up a chit-ton of bad shots before the big three era in boston. we used to watch those walker/pierce Celtics just for the f*ckery.​