Who's your top 5 QB's All Time

[FAH1223]

No he's not you dont know wtf your talking g about

He chokes in big games in January

His best NFC Championship was 2020. All the others were trash even the one he won!

 

[Peruvian Connect]

1. Joe Montana
2. "Air" McNair
3. Mahomes
4. Michael Vick
5. Steve Young

 

[JYoung24]

He chokes in big games in January

His best NFC Championship was 2020. All the others were trash even the one he won!

No he's played against way better teams in ngc championships if anything he's overachieved with the roster he had those teams had no business being in nfc championships

 

[4-Rin]

No it's not.

People are allowed to pick their own personal favourites and not give the default answer that everyone else does. If someone favours 5 other QB more than Brady so be it. They aren't wrong especially when the OP asks who is YOUR all time. You and others interpreted as the greatest in all the universe and others interpreted as their own personal favourites for variety of reason.

Yes it is.

OP didn't say who's your favorite 5 QB. He said Top 5 QB of all time.

If OP makes another thread asking about the Top 5 basketball players of all time and I list

Lebron
Kobe
Curry
Duncan
Kareem

Wouldn't my list be insane with an obvious omission?