Who's your top 5 QB's All Time

[Black White Sox Hat]

Mahomes
Montana
McNair
Marino
Moon

 

[RedBull]

Pat
Tom
Dan
Joe
Steve Young

 

[PHamm]

1. Mahomes
2. Montana
3. Brady
4. Marino
5. Staubach
6. S. Young
7. Rodgers
8. Moon
9. Elway
10. P. Manning

Lamar will enter the top 10 after his first ring

 

[premier58]

No idea how and why some of you have Peyton over Montana. I'd love an explanation.

Manning was a machine, but they are likely mesmerized by the MVP's. Two of them which je didnt deserve, imo(2008/2009). Montana only had 6 years with a dominant No.1(Rice), 5 years with John Taylor. Peyton had 10 with Marvin. 10 with Reggie. 4 with DT(RIP).

Joe is a victim of era differences and I hate it. I bet there are fans talking about how pedestrian his numbers are because they are comparing them to a different era where the passsing game is way less difficult, which greatly upsets me. I am a huge Brady fan, but I never compared their raw numbers, only their league rankings amongst their peers, because I know that it is unfair. Different leagues/rules.

Joe was dominant. Even pre Rice. Look at what he did in 83 and in 84. Qb perfection in SB 19 and Sb24. SB 23 wasnt far off from it, either. Montana was revered in the 80's to an almost mythical degree. I hate that we are getting so far removed from it, that its being lost to history..it shouldnt, epecially in this age of Youtube.

 

[producingfire]

Top 5? Hell nah.

lol I get you. He's not in my top 5 either, but his list is his. Kelly isn't in my top 20 let alone top 5, but to each his own.

 

[producingfire]

Mahomes
Montana
McNair
Marino
Moon

Brady out completely? Woah... that's a dope list though

 

[Cladyclad]

Brady
Mahomes
Peyton
Brett
Rodgers

 

[MoshpitMazi]

I can only speak on QB's I have seen play.

1. Brady
2. Manning,
3. Mahommes
4. Rodgers
5. Vick

Vick top 5? Huh?

 

[MoshpitMazi]

Some of y'all don't have Brady in your top 5?

I don't. He's a cheater.


Barry bonds status 4 me.

Shouldn't have deflated the football nikka!

 

[bear27]

Peyton
Pat
Montana
Marino
Otto Graham. What's wrong? He won 7, that's all that matters right

 

[Dave24]

Subbed

 

[JYoung24]

Rodgers should not be on anyone's top 5.

Playoff choker.

No he's not you dont know wtf your talking g about

 

[JYoung24]

Idc. Dude had his defense get the ball from Brady 3 times and did nothing.

He actually did though he brought his team back

 

[JYoung24]

malhomes Rodgers Manning Brees Steve young the first three aren't in any order

 

[Kunty McPhuck]

Some of y'all don't have Brady in your top 5?

Not having him #1 is actually insane.

No it's not.

People are allowed to pick their own personal favourites and not give the default answer that everyone else does. If someone favours 5 other QB more than Brady so be it. They aren't wrong especially when the OP asks who is YOUR all time. You and others interpreted as the greatest in all the universe and others interpreted as their own personal favourites for variety of reason.