Who's your top 5 QB's All Time

[JLova]

Steve Young literally gets no love. He was an elite athlete who put up video game numbers and won 2 MVPs, a SB MVP and a championship. Excuse my hyperbole, but he is almost like having Vick/Brees into one. What is it? Overshadowed by Montana? Or maybe because he was always upstaged by the Cowboys then Packers? His skillset and production was second to none.

Probably Montana overshadow and the fact that he was athletic. A lot of people do not respect that part of a QB's game. The fact that folk had Aikman ahead of him was infuriating.

 

[Boonapalist]

I love your selections. Im glad you didnt include that mindboggingly overrated Elway on your list

Elway would be nowhere near my top 5. He might be at the bottom half of my 10 though. I’d put Favre up there before him. And Favre would’ve been listed too but his gunslinger ways were too much for me.

 

[premier58]

Brady
Mahomes
Montana
Manning
Rodgers

Literally a perfect list.

 

[Absolut da poet ®]

Brady
Montana
Maholmes
P. Manning
Elway
Rodgers
Brees
Unitas
Marino
Bradshaw

 

[FS4LFE]

Brady
Mahomes
Montana
Peyton
Marino

 

[Heavy_Handz]

Pat Mahomes
Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Peyton Manning
Dan Marino

 

[fifth column]

Randall Cunningham
Mike Vick
Cam Newton
Lamar Jackson
Warren Moon

 

[Chip Skylark]

Patrick
Brady
Marino
Montana
Brett Favre (it’s still fukk him though)

 

[Bboystyle]

Brady
Mahomes
Montana
Rodgers/Marino
Manning

 

[MostHatedBox]

Brady
Montana
Manning
Mahomes ( )
Elway

 

[the next guy]

05. Aaron Rodgers (8.384)

04. Peyton Manning (9.059)

03. Otto Graham (9.207)

02. Joe Montana (10.745)

01. Tom Brady (15.037)

100 Greatest Quarterbacks Since 1950

A countdown, starting from #100, of the greatest quarterbacks of since 1950 (updated for the 2020 season).

quarterbackproject.wordpress.com

Brady
Montana
Manning
Favre
Brees

The 100 best NFL quarterbacks of all time

To celebrate the 100th year of the NFL, we are looking at the 100 best quarterbacks in league history.

ftw.usatoday.com

 

[MooseMouthMthafuga]

That I've watched with my own eyes.
Brady
Peyton
A Rod
Warner
Mahomes.

Far as highlights, I think Dan Marino's the best pocket passer of all time.He'd definitely be in my top 5.Maybe even #1 over all the guys that I actually watched.I'm not ready to crown Mahomes yet.He has to put in at least 10 yrs before I give him any reverence in the GOAT debate.

 

[KidJSoul]

fukk Peyton

 

[Da_Eggman]

Brady
Mahomes
Peyton
Montana
Marino

 

[producingfire]

Kelly?

his top five is his. Kelly was a great qb. but just like Marino, it just wasn't in the cards for him to a Superbowl. Kelly is probably going to be underappreciated because he didn't win the big game though.