Who's your top 5 QB's All Time

[Bboystyle]

If you're top 5, you can't just win one SB

Had the #1 seed and shat the bed in

2011 vs. NYG
2020 vs. TB
2021 vs. SF

And let's not forget how bad he was in 2014 @ SEA.

All the other losses, I can give him slack. But he has been terrible in the NFC Championship. TERRIBLE! The Bucs one was his best performance.

Marino is in alot of top 5 and he has zero rings

 

[JYoung24]

in comparison to Brady who's a sixth round pick he still went high. The 49's definitely missed by selecting Alex Smith, but so did other teams. Aaron Dropped but he was still a first round pick.

shyt tell me about it as a 49er fan I regret that draft damn near every time I see Rodgers play

 

[producingfire]

shyt tell me about it as a 49er fan I regret that draft damn near every time I see Rodgers play

I believe it. Imagine Rogsrs having the same roster Jimmy G had that year they played KC in the Superbowl.

 

[JYoung24]

I believe it. Imagine Rogsrs having the same roster Jimmy G had that year they played KC in the Superbowl.

We would of cooked them

 

[Ku$h Parker]

I believe it. Imagine Rogsrs having the same roster Jimmy G had that year they played KC in the Superbowl.

Rodgers in SF Beats The 2011 Giants at The Stick
A Rod with a P Will led Defense

 

[nairdas]

Peyton Manning
Joe Montana
Tom Brady
Dan Marino
John Elway

 

[Shadow King]

Montana
P Manning
Mr Sunday Night
E Manning
Bree$

Who?

And Eli Top 5

 

[JesusFOREVER]

Brady
Montana
Rodgers
Mahomes
Jackson

 

[Ku$h Parker]

Who?

And Eli Top 5

Rodgers
And Im a Giant Fan so yeah

 

[Heavy_Handz]

Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Pat Mahomes
Peyton Manning
Dan Marino

Outside looking in: John Elway, Johnny Unitis

 

[Waterproof]

Ken Stabler
Johnny Unitas
Joe Montana
Dan Marino
Lamar Jackson

 

[28 Gramz]

Joe Burrow-> Not in terms of superbowls, but they have to see each other to punch their tickets to the Superbowl or advance year over year.

Joe Burrow is Charles Barkley. He might be 2nd best but the gap is so wide it doesn't matter.

 

[28 Gramz]

There’s no argument for Peyton over Pat

5 MVPs and the single season TD record. Pat has lapper him as far the playoffs though.

 

[28 Gramz]

Rodgers has made a lot of shytty teams better and made receivers household names himself too this hate for Rodgers has to stop

Rodgers has choked 3x in a row in the playoffs, 2 of those while being the season MVP with 13 wins. He deserves some blame.

 

[JYoung24]

Rodgers has choked 3x in a row in the playoffs, 2 of those while being the season MVP with 13 wins. He deserves some blame.

I'm not calling the Tampa Bay game a choke he brought his team back and his coach decided not to go for it on the 4th down and my 49ers I can't call the 49ers game from 3 years ago a choke either they had no business even being in the NFC championship that year anyway my
niners own the packers that's not a good matchup for them
I'll give the last playoff game against the 49ers .but Brady sures as hell wouldn't of beat my 9ers and nobody would call him a choker. If anything Rodgers has overachieved with a lot of these packer teams. They would of have been lottery status without him and he's gotten them to NFC championships