TrebleMan
Superstar
Melo had the highest potential, going to the Knicks did him no favors.
Whose career is honestly the most disappointing- CP3, D12 OR Melo?
- Thread starter daboywonder2002
- Start date
Mantis Toboggan M.D.
I’m here for the scraps
He has gotten hurt a lot now. Rookie year lost to a broken kneecap, hurt in the 2013 playoffs, missed significant time in 2013-14, missed most of last year...Derekjackson2
Banned
Melo with ease. Melo is portrayed as a top 5 players at some point but never been in a serious playoff series. Top paid player ion every team he has played on but no championships.
Melo did go to the WCF but all that you said can be applied to chris paul as well
MF_BREW
All Star
Melo
IN 11 SEASONS
CP HAS WON 4 PLAYOFF SERIES
AND BEEN OUT THE 1ST ROUND 4 TIMES...
IN 13 SEASONS
MELO HAS WON 3 PLAYOFF SERIES
AND BEEN OUT THE 1ST ROUND TWICE.
HASNT BEEN IN THE PLAYOFFS IN 4 SEASONS.
CP>>>>MELO
How many legitimate all-stars did both play with during those cited seasons?
Illuminatos
#OVOXO
Flabbo
At least Chris Paul and Dwight make it to the playoffs. Only thing Flabbo has are those weak ass Olympic rings.
At least Chris Paul and Dwight make it to the playoffs. Only thing Flabbo has are those weak ass Olympic rings.
LogicFirst
Banned
CP3 revamped a failed NBA franchise. He should get points for that. But he also fukked off a 3-1 lead in the playoffs. So nevermind.
OnlyInCalifornia
Southern California/Vegas
CP3 and some of that blame should be laid at David Stern's feet for putting him on a cursed team instead of one that would have been a legit contender.
Eastside Get The Money
Veteran
CP3. Dwight is a bytch but his back took him down. He went from dunking 12 feet to barely flushng oops now. Melo just chose the money and NY 
if he would have joined a superteam like everyone else he would be a winner. Even tho the Lakers trade was messed up CP3 just does not win. At all. Ever.
if he would have joined a superteam like everyone else he would be a winner. Even tho the Lakers trade was messed up CP3 just does not win. At all. Ever.CP3. Dwight is a bytch but his back took him down. He went from dunking 12 feet to barely flushng oops now. Melo just chose the money and NY
CP3 win more than Melo though. That's not even debatable. Melo hasn't even made the playoffs for like 4 years. lol. CP3 has also made it to the 2nd round more than Melo despite not having played nearly as long in the NBA.
Eastside Get The Money
Veteran
Like I said Melo is just greedy, but at least Paul has had a very good team in L.A.
Melo had the thugged out Nuggets (Ivo, Jr Smith, Kmart, Ant Carter all on the same team
) and then has been in NY where you know they don't know how to spell win.
Melo is the most disappointing, there isn't a good reason a legit superstar shouldn't be able to get to the playoffs in the EAST no matter who his teammates are
CP3 is getting to the playoffs consistently and winning series and he's still widely considered the #1 pure pg in the NBA
Dwight got 3 DPOY's, multiple 1st Team All NBA, Finals appearance, etc, he's #1 out of the 3
CP3 is getting to the playoffs consistently and winning series and he's still widely considered the #1 pure pg in the NBA
Dwight got 3 DPOY's, multiple 1st Team All NBA, Finals appearance, etc, he's #1 out of the 3
Brief Keef
Superstar
BACK INJURY ENDED D12s PRIME PREMATURELY.
CP3 AND MELO ARE JUST LOSERS.
