"You can't win a SB with Alex Smith"

[yseJ]

I will concede that a team with Alex Smith can win the Super Bowl if 49ers fans can admit that Alex Smith is average (slightly above at BEST).

who's really denying that ?

btw my quote wasnt even giving big props to him...it was in context of that particular thread

 

[yseJ]

the game has changed since dilfer and johnson idiot, more passing, higher scoring

I guess thats why 6 of 10 past SB winners had top 3 defenses ?

and two other winners defenses 1)held one of most prolific regular offenses season to measly 14 pts 2)held SB mvp and regular season mvp-led top ranked offene to only 20 pts, another division winner to 0 offensive pts and another top 3 offense to 17 pts in the playoffs

 

[Sam Peel]

I guess thats why 6 of 10 past SB winners had top 3 defenses ?

and two other winners defenses 1)held one of most prolific regular offenses season to measly 14 pts 2)held SB mvp and regular season mvp-led top ranked offene to only 20 pts, another division winner to 0 offensive pts and another top 3 offense to 17 pts in the playoffs

Last 9 championship qb's
Manning
Rodgers
Brees
big ben
manning
manning
big ben
brady
brady


Alex smith doesn't belong with those names

 

[yseJ]

Last 9 championship qb's
Manning
Rodgers
Brees
big ben
manning
manning
big ben
brady
brady


Alex smith doesn't belong with those names

lol at your stupid alias ass changing the topic. you said the game has changed, didn't you ? I pointed out that you arent winning shyt without top defense.

lol at leaving the 10th qb too, by cherry picking your argument you only look dumber. last 9 qbs...get the fukk outta here, include the 10th one or get the fukk outta here

 

[yseJ]

you can win a SB with any QB really unless theyre just godawful ie kyle boller last year.
alex or fez could definitely win it.

 

[Sam Peel]

lol at your stupid alias ass changing the topic. you said the game has changed, didn't you ? I pointed out that you arent winning shyt without top defense.

lol at leaving the 10th qb too, by cherry picking your argument you only look dumber. last 9 qbs...get the fukk outta here, include the 10th one or get the fukk outta here

Alexis smith will never win a super bowl, deal with it bytch. delusional ass 49er fans

 

[J-MIL]

Nah they ain't winning shyt with dude. Times have changed

 

[Jesus]

So far it's true

Ppl use to say you can't win a title with Dirk as your best player. Dirk proved that statement to be false let's see if AS can do the same

Comparing Dirk to Alex Smith...let's see Alex win MVP and lead his team to the Finals twice.

 

[Bigb41513]

As a niner fan I hope we can win with him. But im not sure. He made some big plays in the offs vs the saints last year that had me like

 

[TheLukieBaby]

is the biggest crock of shyt thats popular among NFL heads these days

so your telling me nikkas like Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson you can win with, but not Alex Smith

so your telling me a nikka like Rex Grossman can get to the SB, yet you can't win with Alex Smith?




why can't you win with a QB putting up stats like this and leading a team like the Niners

nikkas hatin to hate

even though I agree with you and am a niners fan - three years ago you cheered for the Pats and have been a perennial top 5 worst poster for years.

 

[954UAlreadyknow]

I will concede that a team with Alex Smith can win the Super Bowl if 49ers fans can admit that Alex Smith is average (slightly above at BEST). Put Mark Sanchez on the 49ers and I guarantee the exact same results. You guys are leading the league in rushing AND defense right now, all the kid has to do is not fukk up.

Thats it basically. They are elite in the other areas so they can get away with him being there. But if the D or the running game has an off day...... they in trouble

 

[tremonthustler1]

you can win a SB with any QB really unless theyre just godawful ie kyle boller last year.
alex or fez could definitely win it.

he really can't.

 

[yseJ]

Alexis smith will never win a super bowl, deal with it bytch. delusional ass 49er fans

you are an alias
your alias is a two year old joke
you are a bytch whos hiding behind an alias and has no rebuttal to my FACTS

you cherry pick stats to prove your point

but youre right alex smith wont win a superbow

qbs dont win shyt you stupid fukk. TEAM win superbowls. specifically, defenses.

ask drew brees how he has less wins this year than mark sanchez ask him how he and peyton manning each have as many superbowl wins as trent dilfer

 

[yseJ]

he really can't.

a team can win without exceptional qb play. you guys went to AFC championship twice with him a rookie and 2nd year player. so HE won't win the bowl but the team can.

if a qb isnt as braindead as derek anderson or kyle boller, hes good enough to win a superbowl given the defense is good.

you guys give the qb position too much fukking credit

 

[tremonthustler1]

a team can win without exceptional qb play. you guys went to AFC championship twice with him a rookie and 2nd year player. so HE won't win the bowl but the team can.

if a qb isnt as braindead as derek anderson or kyle boller, hes good enough to win a superbowl given the defense is good.

you guys give the qb position too much fukking credit

Ultimately this is part of why I don't want him here, but you can't win with a detriment to your team. That's what Mark is. 88 turnovers (not including 7 fumbles he recovered) in 55 games is too much for a team to have to deal with. It's like having to win while spotting a team points. To win that way is to win in complete spite of him.