FromStLouis
Superstar
1. St. Louis
2. Detroit
3. Chicago
4. Memphis
5. New Orleans
2. Detroit
3. Chicago
4. Memphis
5. New Orleans
Your top 5 all-time Most musically gifted black cities
- Thread starter keon
- Start date
In my mind it goes (in no order)
Detroit - Not just Motown, but also create Techno which eventually evolved into house, EDM and other genres. Not to mention one of the only cities that still sounds unique when it comes to rap/hip-hop.
Memphis - Blues...period.
NYC - The birthplace of rap and jazz arguably the two most important musical genres in the diaspora.
--------------------
All of these cities innovated on genres created by the three above but didn't really create anything new. One could say ATL's invention of trap changed the face of pop music, but ultimately its NYC that should get the credit for rap.
LA
Atlanta
Houston
New Orleans
--------------------
Again, the work their are known for is mostly derivative.
Chicago
Philly
It's shocking with how many black folks is in Alabama that Birmingham/Montgomery are just non-factors when it comes to our artistic culture.
Detroit - Not just Motown, but also create Techno which eventually evolved into house, EDM and other genres. Not to mention one of the only cities that still sounds unique when it comes to rap/hip-hop.
Memphis - Blues...period.
NYC - The birthplace of rap and jazz arguably the two most important musical genres in the diaspora.
--------------------
All of these cities innovated on genres created by the three above but didn't really create anything new. One could say ATL's invention of trap changed the face of pop music, but ultimately its NYC that should get the credit for rap.
LA
Atlanta
Houston
New Orleans
--------------------
Again, the work their are known for is mostly derivative.
Chicago
Philly
It's shocking with how many black folks is in Alabama that Birmingham/Montgomery are just non-factors when it comes to our artistic culture.
Jazz started in New Orleans and then migrated to Chicago and Kansas city after. NY was actually later on the Jazz tip
And Techno actually comes from House music
Roger king
Superstar
Its atlanta, tons of culture and rich heritage
GoAggieGo.
getting blitzed.
1. Memphis (when I pick Memphis, I’m including Memphis as well as surrounding areas such as cities in Mississippi - possibly the most musical state in the US)
New Orleans
New York
New Orleans
New York
ManfromNYCest.1900s
Banned
Detroit-Motor City was able to transition to a mini Black Hollywood because of Barry Gordy
NYC- Hip-Hop wise NYC is the mecca and you can also attribute NYC to disco and new jack-swing music. Even though a lot of new jack-swing music was not rooted in a location, the culture of it was due to the founder, Teddy Riley being a Harlem dude.
LA/COMPTON- Hip-hop was introduced to gang life because of this region of California. They also ushered in certain styles that traveled to other regions and became iconic in fashion and musicality.
ATL-They carried the rap game in the early 2000's and made crunk music popular which even had NYC dudes trying to do it since 50 Cent punked anyone who tried gangsta music in the NYC region. Basically, if you were not Kanye, Lil Wayne, or 50 Cent in the early 2000s you had no choice but to get a job at UPS or try to be affiliated with ATL dudes/music scene and hop on the crunk wave.
Gary, Indianapolis- The Jacksons put Gary on the map. Hell, they put the whole state of Indiana on the map since I never heard anybody associate Indiana with the Colts. Joe Jackson deserved a mural or statue in the town. They should make their house a national landmark. To this day we have never seen a whole family dominate the entertainment business. Katherine and Joe had some superpower DNA.
NYC- Hip-Hop wise NYC is the mecca and you can also attribute NYC to disco and new jack-swing music. Even though a lot of new jack-swing music was not rooted in a location, the culture of it was due to the founder, Teddy Riley being a Harlem dude.
LA/COMPTON- Hip-hop was introduced to gang life because of this region of California. They also ushered in certain styles that traveled to other regions and became iconic in fashion and musicality.
ATL-They carried the rap game in the early 2000's and made crunk music popular which even had NYC dudes trying to do it since 50 Cent punked anyone who tried gangsta music in the NYC region. Basically, if you were not Kanye, Lil Wayne, or 50 Cent in the early 2000s you had no choice but to get a job at UPS or try to be affiliated with ATL dudes/music scene and hop on the crunk wave.
Gary, Indianapolis- The Jacksons put Gary on the map. Hell, they put the whole state of Indiana on the map since I never heard anybody associate Indiana with the Colts. Joe Jackson deserved a mural or statue in the town. They should make their house a national landmark. To this day we have never seen a whole family dominate the entertainment business. Katherine and Joe had some superpower DNA.
@keon no love for the crib? Lol
The whole world stole its sauce from the city and they continue to do so lol. (Mick jagger and the beetles and all them stole from buddy guy and howling wolf. House basically revolutionized music as a whole.)
Quincy jones
Herbie hancock
Kanye
R kelly
Curtis Mayfield
Twista
Earth wind & fire
Lionel Richie grew up in joliet for a little bit( even though he's really from Alabama)
The Jackson's (I'm reaching but Gary is technically part of the Chicagoland area)
The whole world stole its sauce from the city and they continue to do so lol. (Mick jagger and the beetles and all them stole from buddy guy and howling wolf. House basically revolutionized music as a whole.)
Quincy jones
Herbie hancock
Kanye
R kelly
Curtis Mayfield
Twista
Earth wind & fire
Lionel Richie grew up in joliet for a little bit( even though he's really from Alabama)
The Jackson's (I'm reaching but Gary is technically part of the Chicagoland area)
Last edited:
You're right on Jazz...that's my mistake.
But on Techno predates House, but not by alot. When you're talking about house you're talking about really the stuff coming out of Chicago around 1981-82 from Frankie Knuckles and the sort. That then spread through mostly gay bars in the east until eventually taking root in NYC then London heavily. In many ways it's roots are in disco.
Techno on the other hand, was being conceptualized as early as 1978-ish with May/Saunderson etc, in Detroit. Cybotron dropped in 1980 and basically was already becoming an established genre overseas in the mid 80's even before House getting out Chicago. Eventually, the two meshed in the mid-90's and started to become things like deep house, ghettotech, jungle and whatnot.
You could make the argument that one came before the other, i think that's fair, but the legacy of techno far outweighs the legacy of house even if they did blend a bit in the 2000's. It doesn't help that Detroit and Chicago share alot of cultural exchange due to proximity.
NY is where Jazz his critical mass
it was a tuff decision but Maurice White from EWF is originally from Memphis and thats part of the reason why I didn’t pick my own city
The sound they stole from Miami Bass.
Motown
