Hot 97 - One Gotta Go: Kanye West, Dre, Pharrell or Timberland

[L. Deezy]

I Kanye taking a radical departure from hip hop to advant garde electropop and making it work to the point where we still have dudes from Drake, future, and asap making music like that

all trash...

 

[g-ice]

This one is easy brehs Kanye...even though I hate to say it.

Dre gave us Chronic, 2001, and countless classics...so that's default

Pharrell helped push the careers of the Clipse and revitalize Snoop's and Busta's career. Also brought N.O.R.E. onto the mainstream. And he as well has countless classics.

Timbo made careers out of R&B and Pop Rap acts with his Hip Hop sound and has made countless classics (singles) with rappers.

Those three producers have helped push careers with their production moreso than Kanye. That's why I'm taking out Kanye.

 

[Love Sosa]

lmaooo @Kanye being more consistent. The last few records he put out have been pure trash. Where is ALL DAY?

Throughout his whole career (as far as producing) he has not had garbage compared to some stuff Timb and P have put out. All Day was mediocre but it's listenable in a club.

I've never heard Kanye produce a song as bad as, say... I Ain't Heard of That by Slim Thug. I'm not saying Ye is better but he hasn't had anything glaringly bad like that

 

[AyBrehHam Linkin]

i wanna know where yall are getting that this a comparison from a producer standpoint only

 

[The G.O.D II]

all trash...

Doesn't change the fact that album influenced hip hop dramatically

 

[Still Benefited]

I can add more for days.. Y'all nyggas man

Better keep addin,cuz that's probably not even in the top 10 beats on TBA off top of my head

Change Clothes was better,but do I still wanna hear Change Clothes for the beat,or the song in 2015?not really

This beat is much better than that horrible Dirt Off Your SHoulders,I'll give you that,Neptunes and Timbaland had the worst showings on that album ow that you mention it.

 

[Just like bruddas]

Pharell..him and his new black c00nery

 

[BiggWebb79]

LOL at the idiots who are throwing Timbaland to the bushes. probably Ye nuthuggers.

Do y'all simps realize that Ye went to Timbaland for help on one of Ye's biggest cross-over songs, Stronger?

Forget RnB. Timbaland has made better HIP HOP than Ye. "Big Pimpin" is a better hip hop beat than anything Ye's ever made. Missy Elliot's beats run circles around Ye's catalogue. Timbo's stuff goes way harder. It's not even a question.



That's all it is. 98% of the Coli dikkride image, and have never actually heard the music in question.

>>>>>Big Pimpin

 

[thaKEAF]

Timbo

 

[SirBiatch]

>>>>>Big Pimpin

and this is why we don't take Ye supporters seriously

 

[BiggWebb79]

Better keep addin,cuz that's probably not even in the top 10 beats on TBA off top of my head

Change Clothes was better,but do I still wanna hear Change Clothes for the beat,or the song in 2015?not really

This beat is much better than that horrible Dirt Off Your SHoulders,I'll give you that,Neptunes and Timbaland had the worst showings on that album ow that you mention it.

The same album Ye shined on but they won't mention that

 

[BiggWebb79]

and this is why we don't take Ye supporters seriously

 

[I love Latina women]

pharrell


kanye gave us a few great albums

dre gave us eras of great music; eras, muthafukkas!

timbaland gave us an endless amount of great music from workin' with a wide range of artists

pharrell gave us some moments but compared to those other guys, he don't compare

 

[Still Benefited]

This one is easy brehs Kanye...even though I hate to say it.

Dre gave us Chronic, 2001, and countless classics...so that's default

Pharrell helped push the careers of the Clipse and revitalize Snoop's and Busta's career. Also brought N.O.R.E. onto the mainstream. And he as well has countless classics.

Timbo made careers out of R&B and Pop Rap acts with his Hip Hop sound and has made countless classics (singles) with rappers.

Those three producers have helped push careers with their production moreso than Kanye. That's why I'm taking out Kanye.

You gon ignore Blueprint,Kanye pushing his own career,revitalizing Commons career and Twista?

And no I'm not a Kanye stan,but its almost a insult at least based on my own personal taste that Pharell is even in this discussion in regards to hiphop,when I think timeless beats Pharell name don't come up....I know producers do more than that,but being that all parties involved do it all,you gotta weed out the person with the weakest instrumentals....Pharell don't belong here,I don't care how much you nikkas and the media try to force his "genius" on me.,he's overated as shyt.

Really Dre is in a class by himself on this list in terms of hiphop,but Timbaland is on the RNB side....Kanye has produced some crazy shyt that Pharell could never match,its actually disgusting to see Pharell on this list if you want my honest opinion....he makes good pop beats for when rappers wanna crossover? So what,most of it ages like shyt vs wine

 

[WickedSkengman]

nikka I was born in 96 and I heard damn near all of those tracks growing up ... just let me know if you're a sheltered suburban white boy so I can stop devoting my time in this convo

im from the uk wasteman