In their primes, who do you take: Nash or Jkidd

[CrimsonTider]

Neither is a pass first pg

I agree

 

[Tunez]

Kidd hands down

 

[Reggie]

Even though shooting is a huge part of the game and Nash had that over Kidd everything else is in Jason's favor so I would choose him if I had to pick between the two.

 

[SithLawd]

Nash
Much better shooter
Turned a 29 win team into a 60+ win championship contender
We need to dispel with the notion that Nash was created by the system
Nash was the system
Did D'antoni have success with any other team

 

[Tunez]

Nash
Much better shooter
Turned a 29 win team into a 60+ win championship contender
We need to dispel with the notion that Nash was created by the system
Nash was the system
Did D'antoni have success with any other team

Knicks

Made J Lin look like an all star

 

[SithLawd]

Knicks

His best record with the knicks was 42-40

They made their playoff run once they fired him and hired woodson.

 

[JerseyFinest!]

A good defender at PG isn't really necessary to a teams success.

Are you serious??

 

[Tunez]

His best record with the knicks was 42-40

They made their playoff run once they fired him and hired woodson.

Still made the playoffs

 

[MoneyTron]

Today's NBA is way more geared to a player like prime Nash ie super PnR heavy offenses that have a emphasis on 3 point shooting. So I'd probably go with him.

 

[KRiLL (+)]

Steve Nash in a Mike D'Antoni system but im bias because imma Nash Stan..

 

[hayesc0]

Kidd didn't accomplish shyt I don't care about the Dirk championship or his trips to the finals in the weakest conference ever

Did u hear yourself he made 3 finals and u say he did nothing

 

[Eternal Tecate]

Did u hear yourself he made 3 finals and u say he did nothing

Making the conference finals in the West in the mid 2000s > making the finals in the east when Kidd did

Kidd was basically nothing on the Mavs don't even try to use that as an argument

 

[Eternal Tecate]

Nash birthed the modern NBA

 

[JerseyBoy23]

Kidd took Kenyon Martin, Keith Van Horn, Kerry Kittles, Lucious Harris, Todd McCallough and Richard Jefferson to the finals with AI, McGrady, and Carter all in the East.

Of course he was my favorite player on my favorite team.

This video >>> Nash.

 

[GPBear]

Reggie Miller had the best comment on this