Amerie's Tiny Desk Concert Is The Worst Thing I've Seen Today

Doobie Doo

Veteran
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
64,092
Reputation
25,542
Daps
411,525
Reppin
Raleigh, NC
Anyone saying this is good does not know music.

Amerie is pure karaoke. The background singers were off key. The background singers are supposed to save weak vocalist but they were worse than Amerie and brought a shtty lead vocal performance to even shyttier depths.

The best thing about this performance was Backyard Band
 

Geode

All Star
Joined
Apr 18, 2017
Messages
2,018
Reputation
637
Daps
9,259
This was.... interesting.

Plus usually the background singers can carry you and they seemed to struggle. Seemed like the octave was too high for them too.
 

steadyrighteous

Veteran
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
19,085
Reputation
8,580
Daps
116,034
She's a bad singer. She always been a bad singer. And she can't dance.

She was/is pretty, unique looking in the landscape of female artists (Blasian), and she made music that we liked or still like.

The songs are good, and still hold up, we can't take that from her. But go back and listen to 1 Thing. She's essentially yelling on that song and even then her voice is cracking and breaking. Great song, terrible performance, but it was different and it was a banger, so it slides through.

She never was and never will be a good singer. No vocal training or practice can make someone who can't sing, sing well.
 

beenz

Rap Guerilla
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
87,339
Reputation
11,991
Daps
205,903
Reppin
The Chi (South Side)



time-stamped


Screenshot-20250607-190029.png



Screenshot-20250607-190043.png


:mjlol:

shout-out to the go go band though.

BLASEPHEMY :noah:
 

Tribal Outkast

Veteran
Joined
Nov 22, 2016
Messages
39,152
Reputation
6,545
Daps
119,612
Mr Fantastic reach. This performance wasnt as bad as people making it out to be.

As some mentioned, Amerie aint no powerhouse singer from a gospel background or nothing.

She was doing well & seemingly just got winded for the grand finale. The slander dont seem thread worthy, to me
I wish people would realize that everybody don’t have to be Aretha or Whitney out here to make good music. Amerie made some damn good music but I don’t think anybody was saying she’s this amazing singer. We all know why people are mostly clowning her.. it’s just funny to me.. especially with the current singers people celebrate.
 

Negro Caesar

Superstar
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
6,458
Reputation
743
Daps
24,747
When u listened to this song in the day did u think it was great vocals?

But I agree. Subpar vocals live, but the song didnt make me think she had a strong voice in the first place. If Mariah Carey sounded like this then I'd get ur point
 

Tonbo

Pro
Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
200
Reputation
19
Daps
716
I wish people would realize that everybody don’t have to be Aretha or Whitney out here to make good music. Amerie made some damn good music but I don’t think anybody was saying she’s this amazing singer. We all know why people are mostly clowning her.. it’s just funny to me.. especially with the current singers people celebrate.

You don't have to be Aretha or Whitney to be able to sound good singing your own songs. It's the bare minimum any artist should be able to do.
 
Top