Carter III a classic? or nah? - Everyday Struggle Video inside

Is the Carter III a classic?

  • Classic

    Votes: 19 21.6%
  • NO,

    Votes: 46 52.3%
  • no, Carter 2 is doe

    Votes: 23 26.1%

  • Total voters
    88

Killalex

Hov did it so you don't have to
Supporter
Joined
Sep 14, 2012
Messages
3,345
Reputation
-255
Daps
9,803
Reppin
TDE
fukk no. Completely average album that got an immense hype due to weezy bubbling for years. Carter 2 we can have a discussion about.
 

hex

Super Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
39,268
Reputation
20,429
Daps
201,437
The funny thing is, anything you can say about "C3" (as far as popularity, sales, critical acclaim, "shifting the culture") can also be said about "Get Rich Or Die Trying"....and hardly anybody would agree that's a classic. It's just that even though Wayne and 50 are both washed, Wayne is still trendy enough for this to be a topic of discussion.

But yeah....cats got caught up in the hype. I remember Rosenberg called it a classic before it was even out, while it was still in the plastic wrapper. :dead:



Fred.
 

50CentStan

Allahu Akbar
Supporter
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
24,620
Reputation
3,570
Daps
78,876
Reppin
The Ummah!
The funny thing is, anything you can say about "C3" (as far as popularity, sales, critical acclaim, "shifting the culture") can also be said about "Get Rich Or Die Trying"....and hardly anybody would agree that's a classic. It's just that even though Wayne and 50 are both washed, Wayne is still trendy enough for this to be a topic of discussion.

But yeah....cats got caught up in the hype. I remember Rosenberg called it a classic before it was even out, while it was still in the plastic wrapper. :dead:



Fred.




GRODT is an undeniable classic. That album littetaly sold out the stores you couldn't even find it on the shelf after 4 or 5 pm
 

Ya Sinning Mane

Superstar
Joined
Feb 27, 2017
Messages
15,123
Reputation
6,679
Daps
52,055
nope.never was to me.

it was actually garbage instantly after 4th listen and never revisited again.thought it was decent.

i kept smoking blunts playing it like nah this aint it.wayne aint the same.:ld:



nikka had a brisco feature:martin:nikka might as well did another verse and saved time:why:
 

bordeaux

xxx
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
7,879
Reputation
865
Daps
17,002
Reppin
God's Plan
>808s
>rap album

Trilla :fiflaff:
yes, breh. trilla is quite easily a better album. tronic and the renaissance were better albums that yr too.
GRODT is an undeniable classic. That album littetaly sold out the stores you couldn't even find it on the shelf after 4 or 5 pm
i bet u'd get more people to agree on grodt than c3. it has all those qualifying factors and its still great album.
 
Last edited:

NYtymes

All Star
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
1,612
Reputation
146
Daps
5,126
So Wayne got no classics but Cam does???? TheColi kills me

yes he does

R-848895-1378832579-6347.jpeg.jpg

R-991045-1269033596.jpeg.jpg

MI0002210534.jpg
 
Top